Wikia

Game of Thrones Wiki

Changes: Talk:Game of Thrones Wiki

View source

Back to page

m (Reverted edits by 112.157.104.102 (talk | block) to last version by SaganamiFan)
(Top Navigation Bar - Culture & Society)
 
(72 intermediate revisions by 18 users not shown)
Line 67: Line 67:
 
:We have already found a new logo. So new people reading this should disregard what is being written. Cheers [[user:LordofOnions|LordofOnions]] [[User_talk:LordofOnions|(Talk)]] 22:50, August 6, 2011 (UTC)
 
:We have already found a new logo. So new people reading this should disregard what is being written. Cheers [[user:LordofOnions|LordofOnions]] [[User_talk:LordofOnions|(Talk)]] 22:50, August 6, 2011 (UTC)
   
==Spoilers==
+
== House Greyjoy in the slider ==
Why are the characters listed on the front page as dead/alive? That is major spoilers for someone who hasn't read the books or hasn't seen all the episodes of the show yet. I don't think the characters should be grouped like this. I just started watching season 1 and now I know who will die. Thanks a lot. [[Special:Contributions/192.250.34.162|192.250.34.162]] 18:20, March 30, 2012 (UTC)
 
   
The wiki is up to date with the show. We have a [[Template:Spoiler Policy|spoiler policy]] that we follow to exclude books spoilers but we are not aiming to stay spoiler free for aired episodes of the show. I'm sorry you were spoiled but I think you should consider your browsing a bit more carefully while watching a season that first aired 9 months ago.--[[User:Opark 77|Opark 77]] 20:43, April 1, 2012 (UTC)
+
With Season 3 upon us I believe we should replace House Greyjoy, which had a bigger role in Season 2, with Mance Rayder, who will have a huge role after two seasons of being just mentioned.--[[User:Gonzalo84|Gonzalo84]] ([[User talk:Gonzalo84|talk]]) 16:21, March 7, 2013 (UTC)
  +
:Sure! :) Just put Mance in the Greyjoy's spot. {{Template:Buffymybasset/sig}} 16:25, March 7, 2013 (UTC)
  +
::I concur: they're going to take a backseat until season 4-ish, when they introduce Theon and Yara's uncles.--[[User:The Dragon Demands|The Dragon Demands]] ([[User talk:The Dragon Demands|talk]]) 19:49, March 7, 2013 (UTC)
   
You know he has a very good point, right? I mean, I've been watching since episode one and have read all the books so, on a personal level, I'm not worried about having anything spoiled for myself. However, it should be expected that people who may not have seen the show in it's entirety WILL still come here. It's absolutely fine to point out who is dead or not, but it's not cool to do that on the front page. There is no notice for anyone visiting this site via Google (or anything else) that they are about to walk into MASSIVE spoilers on the FRONT page of this website. It's just... rather tactless and rude and an awful, terrible idea to include these details on the single most important and central and central page of the wiki. Especially in a show where the deaths are so important and surprising, a show where the deaths drive much of the most important parts of the story.
+
== Spoiler! ==
-- [[User:Rjcripe|rjcripe]] 08:48, April 9, 2012 (UTC)
+
Some admin please speedy-delete the recently uploaded named image of a certain STILL UNNAMED character! -- [[User:SaganamiFan|SaganamiFan]] ([[User talk:SaganamiFan|talk]]) 21:07, June 4, 2013 (UTC)
   
I think it is incredibly foolish to browse a wiki about a show you are not up to date with. We have details of the latest episode on the front page too. Everything on the site has plot details so there is no way to keep the front page free of plot details. We don't consider character deaths spoilers if the episode they occurred in has aired already.--[[User:Opark 77|Opark 77]] 09:05, April 9, 2012 (UTC)
+
==Update front page character boxes==
   
I just started watching the show, and I came to the Wiki to find information about the map and family trees and stuff. I know how to avoid spoilers, but seriously? Putting the dead characters on the very top of the very front page of the entire site? That's not just foolish, but it's pointless. I think you're mad if you expect no one to get spoiled from that. Whose browsing experience will really be enhanced by showing it? - [[Special:Contributions/159.91.118.126|159.91.118.126]] 16:06, April 16, 2012 (UTC)
+
I think we need to update the front page character boxes: the four by four, sixteen characters presented as front page portals. We must remember that while we regular editors know where everything is, casual new readers often access most things on the wiki by randomly clicking on shiny things on the front page about major characters.
   
''Exactly'' my point. I mean, seriously... anyone who has watched the show in it's entirety ''already'' knows who is dead and who is alive (therefore explicitly indicating who has died on the front page is a futile effort) and anyone who hasn't will have nearly all the most suspenseful and eventful scenes spoiled for them ''just'' by visiting the ''front'' page. Again, no one is saying remove all spoilers from the wiki, all people want is to have the spoilers removed from the ''front'' page. I know I, for one, do visit wikis for shows I have not finished for basic, background info. I don't read very far into the websites, but to pretend that the only people who visit wikis are those who have watched the show in it's entirety is completely ignorant. Just bury the info skin deep... just past the front page (and maybe opening paragraphs and section headers of pages, although that is debatable and I personally don't care if they contain spoilers). But I think what I'm all saying here is really besides the point now. Since it has (apparently) been decided to only include ''living''characters in the front page's character portal, this discussion is essentially pointless (btw, excellent call whoever decided that--it's really the best compromise and perhaps the only one that will actually satisfy both parties and stances on this issue).
+
Out of the sixteen, there are a few locks:
EDIT: Oh, and the whole thing about the spoiler policy--no where in that policy is anything stated that the front page is an O.K. and appropriate space for spoilers. So pointing to that as a qualifier for front page spoilers doesn't quite work...
 
-- [[User:Rjcripe|rjcripe]] 03:01, April 24, 2012 (UTC)
 
   
:::....you buffoon. This wiki is written from the standpoint that readers will have watched the most recent episode. EVERY TV wiki functions this way. You're openly asking us to what? Cater to people who didn't even watch the ''last'' season yet? Why would we even have information on episode 2, "the Kingsroad", when that might spoil it for the people who only watched episode 1?! I mean seriously, sit down and ask yourself, functionally, how the hell would you ever institute such a policy? You're asking for family trees to be a snapshot of what they were in Season 1?
+
*Ned Stark's surviving children - 4 boxes (Sansa, Arya, Jon, Bran (Rickon doesn't get a slot))
  +
*The core Lannisters - 5 boxes (Tywin, Cersei, Jaime, Tyrion, Joffrey)
  +
*Daenerys Targaryen - carrying the entire Essos storyline
   
:::Yikes..."to pretend that the only people who visit wikis are those who have watched the show in its entirety"....that's the CENTRAL ASSUMPTION of this wiki! This is a wiki devoted SPECIFICALLY to the TV show, not even the books. This show is slated to run about eight seasons. Take "The Wire" for example, that ran five seasons...are you honestly saying that a wiki devoted to "The Wire" should, even during season 4, have a strict spoilers policy that considers ANYTHING beyond season 1 to be a spoiler?
+
So those are 10 out of 16 which right away I don't think anyone will disagree with.
   
:::I've checked your contributions tab, you've never really contributed to ''any'' wiki including this one. What ''are'' you?--[[User:The Dragon Demands|The Dragon Demands]] ([[User talk:The Dragon Demands|talk]]) 05:10, April 24, 2013 (UTC)
+
Next, while not a complete lock, I'm fairly certain that we should include Stannis (standing in for his associated characters and subplot too), as well as Littlefinger and Varys.
   
:::Once again, Dragon Demands, you're insulting people and being rude right off the bat. How is it that the other Admins can get their points across without insulting people, yet you can't seem to do it? I have never seen an Admin talk to people the way you do. Ever. Admins are supposed to set the bar and lead by example. You were rude before you became an Admin, but you haven't changed at all. I'm probably going to get banned for speaking out against you, but I can't sit back anymore. It's ridiculous. 
+
These 13 characters are already on the front page.
:::[[User:Draevan13|<font face="" color="#000000">'''DRAEVAN13'''</font>]][[File:Targaryen.JPG|26px|link=User talk:Draevan13]] 13:29, April 24, 2013 (UTC)​​
 
   
::::Actually I'm insulting this guy because I'm already on the verge of banning him for the way he insulted [[User:Greater good]] over on his talk page; out of context this may seem harsh but there have been ongoing problems with this guy. Yes, my overall command style is to serve the "greater good" by being willing to just plain throw out the few bad apples. I know my methods are harsh, [http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ceqNcCUUakE but I get results, damn it!] (why would you be in danger of banning? You're a regular contributor and follow the rules).--[[User:The Dragon Demands|The Dragon Demands]] ([[User talk:The Dragon Demands|talk]]) 15:33, April 24, 2013 (UTC)
+
What's at issue is the next three spots, which are currently:
  +
*Theon
  +
*Melisandre
  +
*Sandor "The Hound" Clegane
   
::::Are you referring to his comment on the "Prose" section of GreaterGood's talk page? If so, I don't see how that's rude, he's calmly and clearly explaining his point of view. In fact, it's a lot more polite than how you usually respond to people.
+
I've seen other news sites trying to rank characters based on the raw number of episodes they appear in: this is utterly absurd, given that certain important characters may appear in few yet pivotal scenes, while others may only appear as accessories of other characters (Bronn technically appears in most episodes Tyrion does). Moreover I thought that statistical study was really interesting in which someone figured out what percentage of characters each character spoke in Season 3 - Bronn actually had a line or two more than ''Catelyn Stark''.
::::​And once again, the other Admins get the job done while being polite and without insulting people. You like using that McGarnigle reference, except you're not a cop fighting crime. You're an Admin on a Wikia site. Your methods don't have to be harsh to get the job done. [[User:Draevan13|<font face="" color="#000000">'''DRAEVAN13'''</font>]][[File:Targaryen.JPG|26px|link=User talk:Draevan13]] 17:06, April 24, 2013 (UTC)
 
   
== House Greyjoy in the slider ==
+
So the choice should be based on "who is important in the storyline", which will be in part based on what the spoiled know will be happening this season based on the books (as it always is).
   
With Season 3 upon us I believe we should replace House Greyjoy, which had a bigger role in Season 2, with Mance Rayder, who will have a huge role after two seasons of being just mentioned.--[[User:Gonzalo84|Gonzalo84]] ([[User talk:Gonzalo84|talk]]) 16:21, March 7, 2013 (UTC)
+
We should probably pick from people actually listed as "main cast" in [[Season 4]], not "recurring".
:Sure! :) Just put Mance in the Greyjoy's spot. {{Template:Buffymybasset/sig}} 16:25, March 7, 2013 (UTC)
 
::I concur: they're going to take a backseat until season 4-ish, when they introduce Theon and Yara's uncles.--[[User:The Dragon Demands|The Dragon Demands]] ([[User talk:The Dragon Demands|talk]]) 19:49, March 7, 2013 (UTC)
 
   
== Spoiler! ==
+
Well, this was a mouthful. Now we come to The Point:
Some admin please speedy-delete the recently uploaded named image of a certain STILL UNNAMED character! -- [[User:SaganamiFan|SaganamiFan]] ([[User talk:SaganamiFan|talk]]) 21:07, June 4, 2013 (UTC)
+
  +
Sandor Clegane is an important character, but in terms of "geo-politics" in a continent spanning war, he isn't Tywin or Stannis. Then again Balon Greyjoy shouldn't get a slot either due to his rare appearance. But Sandor is so closely tied to other storylines (Joffrey before, Arya now) that I really don't think he needs his own slot.
  +
  +
I'm not sure about Melisandre - she *is* important, but also a bit redundant with Stannis.
  +
  +
I'm not really sure what to do with Theon - he *is* important, even more than Melisandre (given that he doesn't overlap with someone, as she does Stannis). But we don't know how much screentime he'll have. Part of this decision should be based on screentime.
  +
  +
So my suggestion is that at the very least, we should replace The Hound with Margaery Tyrell, due to her importance in the storyline, significant scenes, and representation of an entire political faction (House Tyrell) in the wider war. Does anyone think Melisandre or Theon should be replaced with someone else?--[[User:The Dragon Demands|The Dragon Demands]] ([[User talk:The Dragon Demands|talk]]) 05:02, February 2, 2014 (UTC)
  +
  +
Okay I've had time to think on this:
  +
  +
Theon should stay on the front page, Margaery Tyrell should replace Sandor Clegane as I said, but also, I think Brienne of Tarth should replace Melisandre.
  +
  +
Theon should stay on the front page -- He is a major character and remains a major character. The only reason we *might* want to leave him out is if he doesn't have a lot of screentime - similar to how Jaime Lannister was back-burnered in book/season 2. He disappears for books 3 and 4, presumed dead, but then book 5 reveals that he was kept prisoner by Ramsay and horrifically tortured (the TV show chose to present this in the chronological order that it happened). However, judging from the trailers they might be moving up some of Theon's material from Book 5 - or if nothing else will apparently show more of his torture at the hands of Ramsay (Theon is *literally unrecognizable* by the end, even people who knew him well). But if Theon will have prominent screentime he should stay.
  +
  +
The best way to define the major characters is generally those who were POV narrators in the books. Sandor was never a POV narrator (Melisandre did later narrate a chapter or two but not that much). The different POV narrations show the different story threads from different angles (i.e. Sansa shows what's happening in King's Landing, Theon shows what's happening in Winterfell, etc.). So it serves as a starting point for readers to branch off from.
  +
  +
Keeping this in mind, I still think that Margaery Tyrell should replace Sandor Clegane. Margaery actually isn't a POV narrator but she is much more important in the story, shows entirely different and major plot threads - while Sandor is either in Sansa or Arya's POV narrations.
  +
  +
Melisandre is fairly important, but her storyline will mostly overlap with Stannis's, which he already covers on the front page.
  +
  +
Meanwhile, Brienne of Tarth became a POV narrator starting at this point in the books, and her storyline goes in entirely separate directions (she reached King's Landing as promised but the Starks are dead including Catelyn so her prisoner exchange is a moot point, and her native Stormlands have mostly bent the knee to the Lannisters post-Blackwater).
  +
  +
Interestingly, trailers suggest that they'll *invent* some scenes for Brienne with the Tyrells - I assume having them argue about what all of the Renly supporters are doing now that he has died - and why the Tyrells are supporting the Lannisters now. Pointing out that, like Brienne, they'd never support Stannis (he'd never forgive them for supporting Renly) so they're kind of stuck - but the Tyrells don't exactly *like* the Lannisters either. Good politics stuff - too soon they forget that Brienne is actually the heir to a noble House from the Stormlands (though I don't think the Tarths are that powerful). It also helps that Brienne of Tarth is a fairly popular character, whome TV viewers will want to search for first.
  +
  +
So the other 13 were mostly locks, Theon I only hesitated on because I thought he might have reduced screentime but apparently he doesn't. Meanwhile, I think Sandor Clegane and Melisandre are fairly redundant, while Margaery Tyrell and Brienne of Tarth are more important and should be given their spots on the front page portal.--[[User:The Dragon Demands|The Dragon Demands]] ([[User talk:The Dragon Demands|talk]]) 18:13, February 3, 2014 (UTC)
  +
  +
We're going to leave the character portal as it is until Season 5 starts to gear up.
  +
  +
Looking ahead, out of 25 available slots, we'll be removing the dead characters Tywin and Joffrey, and also Sandor Clegane (whose status is unconfirmed, but who hasn't reappeared in the books since).
  +
  +
I anticipate no major changeups. The five remaining Stark children (including Jon, but minus Rickon) plus Samwell Tarly make six. Cersei, Jaime, and Tyrion make nine. Margaery, Stannis, Daenerys, and Brienne will also remain (due to being viewpoint characters for their respective subplots/factions). This brings us up to 13. Also keep Roose/Ramsay/Reek to make 16.
  +
  +
Joffrey's slot will be replaced by Tommen, that seems obvious. Leaving us with TWO free slots.
  +
  +
Also I think Littlefinger should stay (he'll probably appear in Sansa scenes at the Eyrie)....but I don't know if Varys will be reappearing in Season 5 or not (not much spoilers to say that he's not present "on page" for much of the next book, but people get letters or messages from him so his "presence" is felt, and the TV series might just decide to actually show what he was doing "offscreen", just as it gave Loras and Renly stuff which was "off screen" in the books)....tell you what: Varys is important enough as a "faction" unto himself that we'll leave him in his front page slot, but if it turns out that he doesn't appear in the first couple of Season 5 episodes we'll shuffle him out (possibly to be shuffled back later).
  +
  +
So two clearly free slots...
  +
  +
The reason I don't want to put Davos or Melisandre in is because they're basically redundant with Stannis. They're part of the Stannis subplot (similarly, Bran Stark's companions are redundant with Bran).
  +
  +
Ah! I know. If the books are any guide, the next book shifts a lot of focus on the internal politics of Dorne and the Iron Islands (and the Greyjoys REALLY got shorted in Season 4). So we'll update it to have Yara Greyjoy take one slot.
  +
  +
Meanwhile, for our "viewpoint Dorne" character I'd like to put Myrcella...tying in with the fact that the character portal loosely focuses on "Stark vs Lannister" as the core dynamic (or "Lannisters vs their clear enemies, Stark/Baratheon). And they said they're going to give a lot of screentime to Myrcella next season (again, much like Renly/Loras, it's stated that she's doing a lot of stuff "off screen" in the Dorne chapters, which are told from Arianne Martell's perspective). But they want to focus on the Myrcella/Trystane romance, which is good.
  +
  +
So the plan is, we keep the character portal as it is, until Februaryish when the first trailer for Season 5 comes out. Then we:
  +
  +
*Swap out Joffrey for Tommen.
  +
*Swap out Tywin for Myrcella.
  +
*Swap out the Hound for Yara Greyjoy.
  +
  +
And we'll leave Varys in until the first episode or two of Season 5, and see if he's actually in it that much.--[[User:The Dragon Demands|The Dragon Demands]] ([[User talk:The Dragon Demands|talk]]) 01:31, July 2, 2014 (UTC)
  +
  +
==Season 4 Wiki skin==
  +
  +
We will soon have to choose a new skin for the wiki in Season 4. In Season 2 we used the promotional image of someone grasping the crown (I miss that one). In Season 3 we used the promotional images of everyone's faces - which were fun but now look like heads staring at me - well, characters I like, but it looks weird for people looking over my shoulder (haha).
  +
  +
So what should the Season 4 skin be? Some may argue for that dragon shadow poster thing but I don't think it's distinct enough.
  +
  +
I think it might be good to use images from the [[Red Wedding]] - specifically, repeating that image of the burning Stark banner: http://gameofthrones.wikia.com/wiki/File:Mhysa_burning_stark_banner.png (not necessarily this exact screenshot of it). I really liked the color palette in Season 2 of the hand reaching for a crown on a burning field. And I guess the thing I didn't like about the Season 3 ones is how blue they are - a very cold color palette. Yes, I know "''Ice'' and Fire". But I think a burning Stark banner will emphasize how much chaos and destruction is going on.
  +
  +
Well, that's my opinion.--[[User:The Dragon Demands|The Dragon Demands]] ([[User talk:The Dragon Demands|talk]]) 05:08, February 2, 2014 (UTC)
  +
  +
: I just read this, and I support adding a burning Stark banner to the wiki skin, which is an brilliant idea ''The Dragon''. If I may ask, have you progressed anywhere with this future skin for the wiki? Just curious! :) – [[User:The Snow Prince|The Snow Prince]] ([[User talk:The Snow Prince|talk]]) 20:31, May 12, 2014 (UTC)
  +
  +
...''I'' have no experience with changing wiki skins. That's why I was asking.
  +
  +
But we were discussing making a new skin for a new season before Season 4 began...now Season 4 is over and we're still stuck with the damned fish-heads staring at me from Season 3. What progress is being made on this?--[[User:The Dragon Demands|The Dragon Demands]] ([[User talk:The Dragon Demands|talk]]) 15:06, June 30, 2014 (UTC)
  +
  +
== Bran ==
  +
Er... some genius managed to destroy the [[Bran Stark]] article by turning it into a redirect on itself... -- [[User:SaganamiFan|SaganamiFan]] ([[User talk:SaganamiFan|talk]]) 13:13, April 7, 2014 (UTC)
  +
  +
: It's been fixed.--{{The Boy Who Cried Direwolf/signiture}} 13:18, April 7, 2014 (UTC)
  +
  +
  +
My two cents: maybe instead of changing out the background each new season, we could decide on a permanent background image? Maybe the Iron Throne itself, as the series is "Game of Thrones". '''[[User:Draevan13|<span style=color:red>DRAEVAN13</span>]]'''
  +
[[Category:User Signature Templates]] 16:16, August 6, 2014 (UTC)
  +
  +
Okay, I tried loading a placeholder new background I made up...and it instantly reverts back to the default, within a few seconds. When you're in "Theme designer" mode, the history of the past 10 revisions says an IP address automatically reverted my new upload seconds after I made it. Why?
  +
  +
This update should have happened at the beginning of Season 4 but we're still using the skin from Season 3. I'm not the best with design, but I tried to load up SOME form of a background just to get away from the crappy fish-eyed posters staring dead at us.--[[User:The Dragon Demands|The Dragon Demands]] ([[User talk:The Dragon Demands|talk]]) 03:30, August 7, 2014 (UTC)
  +
  +
==Redesign==
  +
  +
I'm making an overhaul of the front page; before the Season 4 premiere I moved things around a bit on the front page for ease of access.
  +
  +
Now, I have set up collapsible menus for major topics like "Noble Houses" or "Organizations".
  +
  +
I've had some library studies training, and the big point you have to remember is "casual fans don't even know what they're looking for" and know less than we do.
  +
  +
So ''we'' know where the "Kingsguard" page is, but unless they new the proper name and put it in a search engine, they wouldn't know how to find it through general browsing.
  +
  +
Also we need to support new fans who just come on here to browse, without even a specific topic to look up.
  +
  +
Basically they're called "access points" -- the names which TV-first viewers will try to look up to find information. So far we've been mostly using the Episode Guide as the main access point: people come on here, read an episode guide, and clink on the internal links. Also on the front page our main access points have been the Character pages (people look up "Arya Stark", "Tyrion Lannister", "Jon Snow", etc.) - We needed more "access points" on the front page itself, i.e. a menu for "Culture and Society" so people will know we even have a page on "Heraldry" or "Knighthood".
  +
  +
I've also increased the number of characters on the front page menu from 16 to 25.
  +
  +
Given that the season has already started I didn't have time to make images customed to fit the menu screen, so some of them are a bit oddly shaped. The Boy Who Cried Direwolf was already helping out with the Bolton character images. But the important thing was to have the menus made; we can tweak and refine the images as we go.
  +
  +
I'll continue to refine the new front page menus.--[[User:The Dragon Demands|The Dragon Demands]] ([[User talk:The Dragon Demands|talk]]) 15:43, April 16, 2014 (UTC)
  +
  +
: It looks fantastic. I can always help out with reconfiguring the portal images.--{{The Boy Who Cried Direwolf/signiture}} 16:07, April 16, 2014 (UTC)
  +
  +
===Navigation bar redesign===
  +
  +
The Navigation Bar hasn't been significantly updated in two years, since inactive Admin KarinS put in a basic setup.
  +
  +
I have redesigned the navigation bar from scratch.
  +
  +
The old setup had this layout for the "Characters" navigation tab:
  +
  +
http://gameofthrones.wikia.com/wiki/MediaWiki:Wiki-navigation?oldid=12950
  +
  +
Category:Characters | Characters
  +
Category:Characters | All characters
  +
Category:Status: Alive | Characters, alive
  +
Category:Status: Dead | Characters, dead
  +
Category:Status: Unsure | Characters, status uncertain
  +
Category:Actor | Actors
  +
Category:Actor | All actors
  +
Category:Status: Active | Actors, active
  +
Category:Status: Not hired | Actors, not hired
  +
Category:Status: Role ended | Actors, role ended
  +
  +
This was absurd.
  +
  +
''Who'' would come onto this wiki and attempt to navigate through the characters on the basis of who is dead and who is alive? Or "uncertain"? Making the actor navigation copy this, based on "role ended" or "active", only compounded the problem.
  +
  +
The thought just occurred to me that I've been staring at this ''bizarre'' navigation system for two years and never thought to ask about it.
  +
  +
I have completely rebuilt this into a new setup based on House affiliation: Stark-Tully, Lannister, Tyrell, Targaryen, etc. There was limited space so I couldn't fit in more than seven groups....but I think this is far superior to what we've had until now.
  +
  +
Meanwhile, I completely renamed the "Actors" tab as "Production", and gutted it. It is impossible with limited nav bar space to list all actors in a meaningful way, and it was silly to list them based on "active" or "Role ended". Now, "actors" is only one link in the production tab, the others being changed to things like "Writers" and "Directors", plus direct links to major ones like "Gemma Jackson"/"Deborah Riley", and Michele Clapton.
  +
  +
Moreover, I think many of you have seen the complaints about the navigation setup for episodes. They used to be based simply on "Category - Season 1" ...which presents a ''random shuffle'' of the episodes.
  +
  +
I think you've all seen complaints about this.
  +
  +
Anyway the thought struck me that there's no...reason, to use a random shuffle "category" link ''when there are only ten episodes in a season''. So I redesigned it as a numbered list with redirects to the correct episodes pages. Hopefully this will help things run smoother.
  +
  +
These are just the nav bar on the top of every page, though; I've also been fine tuning the new expandable nav box system on the front page. --[[User:The Dragon Demands|The Dragon Demands]] ([[User talk:The Dragon Demands|talk]]) 04:15, May 4, 2014 (UTC)
  +
  +
  +
Should we change pictures of characters in portal? New poll could also be useful, like something like Who will win Tyrion's trial, Oberyn Martell or ser Gregor Clegane. --[[User:-Gladiatus-|Gladiatus]] ([[User talk:-Gladiatus-|talk]]) 08:24, May 25, 2014 (UTC)
  +
  +
== Jaime's picture ==
  +
  +
Jaime Lannister isn't rocking the beard or dirty hair anymore. Is it time that his picture be changed on here?
  +
  +
--[[User:Iron Bank|Iron Bank]] ([[User talk:Iron Bank|talk]]) 17:05, June 19, 2014 (UTC)
  +
  +
== "Episodes" drop-down menu ==
  +
  +
Because it is the "'''Episodes'''" drop-down menu, shouldn't Second Sons, The Bear and the Maiden Fare, and The Rains of Castamere be linked directly to their respective '''Episode''' page rather than the disambiguation page?  --[[User:Iron Bank|Iron Bank]] ([[User talk:Iron Bank|talk]]) 19:35, June 27, 2014 (UTC)
  +
  +
:Absolutely. Sorry, I forgot about disambiguation pages when I redesigned the navigation bar during Season 4.--[[User:The Dragon Demands|The Dragon Demands]] ([[User talk:The Dragon Demands|talk]]) 20:10, June 27, 2014 (UTC)
  +
  +
:You can only put 10 items in a list, so for the "characters" dropdown lists, I tried to fill them in. It's by faction, not family, so it includes "Baratheon and Baratheon retainers" you see. "Stark" is actually "Stark-Tully" (whole names don't always fit in the navbar itself). The Starks and Tullys were pretty obvious (Eddard and Catelyn, plus six children = 8, plus Edmure and Brynden = 10). Lannister was also obvious (Tywin, Tywin's three children, Cersei's three children = 7. Plus Kevan and Lancel, the only other blood Lannisters seen on the show, gives us 9. Used to just cut off at "Martyn" before I realized I only had room for one more...so I figured, "might as well put Ser Pounce" (he's popular and people would look for his page). Baratheon included the three brothers Robert, Stannis, Renly. Plus Gendry gives 4. Brienne is a major character from the Stormlands and served Renly so she's in there to make 5. Plus Selyse and Shireen to round out the living ones, core remaining family with Stannis, gives us seven. So then I added Davos, Salladhor, and Melisandre to round out Stannis's retainers. Targaryen also mostly obvious: Daenerys, Viserys, Mad King Aerys II, Maester Aemon, Khal Drogo = 5. Rhaegar was important enough to also put in there to make 6. Round it out with Daenerys's major retainers: Jorah, Bartistan, Missandei, Grey Worm. Didn't have enough room for Daario, but he's the most recent one, and I kind of think Missandei and Grey Worm need more attention. I added the ''currently'' known Greyjoys, Martells, and Tyrells, but they each fell short of 10, but that's what we have.--[[User:The Dragon Demands|The Dragon Demands]] ([[User talk:The Dragon Demands|talk]]) 02:54, June 28, 2014 (UTC)
  +
  +
=="Actors" menu==
  +
  +
As I've said the old navigation bar was bizarre, using up space on nav icons for "actors, current", "actors, role ended", "actors, uncertain" etc.
  +
  +
I shorted this to just one icon for "All actors" which takes you to the category page. But the way it works is that it includes a dropdown menu...of what I ''thought'' would be a random collection of actors every time, but in fact were always the same ones. I've now realized this was also bizarre because it kept showing "Tamzin Merchant" which isn't really relevant at this point.
  +
  +
The problem is that if it's not showing random actors each time (and that wasn't very useful either), the dropdown menus '''can only list a maximum of ten entries'''.
  +
  +
So I decided to list the actor pages people are most likely to be looking for, coming here to read (most of our actor articles aren't very substantive, except for a few key cast members anyway).
  +
  +
So the short list I made up is this:
  +
  +
*Peter Dinklage
  +
*Kit Harington
  +
*Emilia Clarke
  +
*Maisie Williams
  +
*Sophie Turner
  +
*Lena Headey
  +
*Nikolaj Coster-Waldau
  +
*Natalie Dormer
  +
  +
I think these are the major ones most people want to look up, and fairly obvious. Problem is that it was only easy for these ''eight'', but we've got ten spaces to fill:
  +
  +
'''What are two more actor articles that people would be searching for, which are substantive, and/or which are very popular?'''
  +
  +
  +
....I don't know if we should put Rose Leslie or not. People will be looking for her but her character just died. But there's also Liam Cunningham, Carice van Houten, Isaac Hempstead-Wright....oh of course, GWENDOLINE CHRISTIE!
  +
  +
Tell you what, I'll put up Gwen and Rose for now, and we'll eventually remove Rose during the lead-up to Season 5. --[[User:The Dragon Demands|The Dragon Demands]] ([[User talk:The Dragon Demands|talk]]) 01:25, July 3, 2014 (UTC)
  +
  +
==Production menu==
  +
  +
I've redesigned the "Production" part of the "Production" menu to be two dropdown lists: one is "Production by department" listing "Deborah Riley- Set designer", "Michele Clapton - Costume designer", etc. The other is "Production topics": things like "Production timeline", "Title sequence", "Game of Thrones (TV series)", and "Differences Between books and TV series".--[[User:The Dragon Demands|The Dragon Demands]] ([[User talk:The Dragon Demands|talk]]) 21:03, July 5, 2014 (UTC)
  +
  +
== Characters on Main Page ==
  +
  +
I think it's time to change the character images on the main page. For starters Tywin, Joffrey and the Hound are dead or presumed dead in the Hound's case, and Roose isn't played by one of the starring cast. Also I think the images themselves could do with updating. Brienne's in particular looks quite bad. I'm not good with images so I'm more asking for help on this one. Possible new order could be...
  +
  +
Bran, Arya, Sansa, Jon, Samwell,<br />Cersei, Jaime, Tyrion, Bronn, Margaery,<br />Stannis, Melisandre, Davos, Petyr, Varys,<br />Dany, Jorah, Brienne, Ramsay, Reek.<br />
  +
  +
What do you guys think?
  +
[[User:Rachel P|<font face="Parchment" size=7 color="#D4A017">''R''</font><font face="Parchment" size=6 color="#D4A017">''achel''</font>]] [[User talk:Rachel P|<font face="Parchment" size=6 color="#D4A017">''P''</font>]] 03:16, July 19, 2014 (UTC)
  +
  +
I wrote about that at length a bit further up this page, but thanks for being on top of this.
  +
  +
Basically, we're still in "post Season 4 mode" but not yet "pre Season 5 mode". As soon as the first teaser trailer for Season 5 comes out, we start redesigning for Season 5 (Some point in late January at the latest).
  +
  +
MANY people are still catching up on Season 4, through Netflix, HBO Go, etc.
  +
  +
Most of the 20 characters in the front page box are "locks" that we wouldn't remove (the core Starks and the core Lannisters).
  +
  +
By a process of elimination, my general idea for how we'd eventually change it when gearing up for Season 5 is:
  +
  +
*Swap out Joffrey for Tommen.
  +
*Swap out Tywin for Myrcella.
  +
*Swap out the Hound for Yara Greyjoy.
  +
  +
We've got 4 main Starks on the first row (including Jon Snow; Robb is dead and Rickon is off-screen), plus Samwell Tarly (he's a POV narrator at this point, and stuff like him escaping Craster's Keep with Gilly is "told" entirely from his perspective even within the TV series).
  +
  +
We have to keep the three core Lannisters: Cersei, Jaime, Tyrion. We're eventually going to swap out Tywin for Myrcella (advanced reports say they've going to ''invent'' new scenes for Myrcella, which plausibly happened "off screen" in the books -- which is great, she's one of my favorite characters), plus Tommen replacing Joffrey because he's king now (he doesn't do that much due to being so young, but the plots at court center around him).
  +
  +
So the first half of the boxes are fairly obvious. The second half gets more tricky:
  +
  +
At the very least, we ''need'' Daenerys, Stannis, and Margaery, given that they are "faction leaders" (Targaryen, Baratheon of Dragonstone, and...Margaery is more the "face" of Tyrell political intrigue in the show than Loras or Mace ever were, while I don't know if Olenna will reappear...if we have only one Tyrell slot I'd use Margaery over Olenna, whether to have Olenna replace one of the others is a separate issue...)
  +
  +
Yara Greyjoy will replace the Hound because he's presumed dead, and because after the ironborn were ''shoved completely to the side'' in Season 4, I can only hope that they will follow the ironborn-heavy subplots of Book 4 which happen after Tywin dies (well, unless we count the Moat Cailin stuff; but as a "political viewpoint", Season 2 showed us Balon and Yara planning....now there's been no Balon and Yara is in only 3 minutes of screentime). Littlefinger remains the "faction leader" of the Vale I guess and by the books should have more to do next season, he's a major player. I'm...not sure, if Varys will be in Season 5 that much so that's up in the air (after he flees King's Landing he isn't "on the page" in the book, then later they give an infodump retroactively explaining what he was doing in that time (similar to how Stannis would be "off screen" for chapters at a time in book 2, but the TV series decided to just show what he did chronologically). If Varys isn't in the first two episodes of Season 5 we might want to swap it out for Olenna Tyrell...but what if she doesn't reappear in Season 5 either? (And of course, if Dianna Rigg wins an Emmy Award next month, all previous arguments fall by the wayside and we put her on the front page!)
  +
  +
The final line of the character boxes is the most random. As I said Yara will get the Hound's spot, and Brienne of Tarth needs her spot. This leaves the "Bolton" perspective of Roose, Ramsay, and Reek. Theon/Reek is a "Viewpoint" character so I think he should be in there. Ramsay is one of the major villains.
  +
  +
Fundamentally, though, I didn't put together the character boxes according to arbitrary TV definitions of "main cast member" or "credited as a guest actor". This is based on the book/story mythos, how relatively important they are (technically Bronn appears more than Catelyn, but he isn't as important within the overall plot; Tywin doesn't relatively have that much screentime in Season 1, but he's very important). Roose is one of the ''main'' villains in the story (he's ruling the North now for the Lannisters and personally killed Robb Stark). He didn't appear that much in Season 4 but his presence was large (everything Ramsay is doing is to impress him) and going by the books, now that he's back in the North he'll have even more to do in Season 5 (securing Bolton rule over the other beaten Northern houses).
  +
  +
....wait let's see now...
  +
  +
You're suggesting we include Bronn, Melisandre, Davos, and Jorah.
  +
  +
....well my argument for that is that they're basically "access points". The infoboxes are how people who don't know how to navigate a wiki access different sub-plots. Why have a box for Rickon in Season 2, when Bran is always with him? Etc. The problem is that Bronn isn't very independent of Tyrion in the TV series/books, and Davos and Melisandre are also pretty much always with Stannis. There's just too much overlap. Similarly, all of Jorah's scenes involve Daenerys.
  +
  +
...but then we've got the whole "musical chairs" effect: the design you suggested leaves out Tommen...and he's kind of more important than Bronn, what with being the king on the Iron Throne. Choosing between the two I'd put Tommen over Bronn. The Hound was such a major character in Season 4 that I don't think we should replace him with Melisandre (particularly because the Hound won't be appearing after this, so let him have his time in the limelight).
  +
  +
Brienne's image is indeed bad, it's just what I had available at the time. Yes it needs updating. It would drastically be sped up if anyone loads a properly cropped and sized Brienne image (though then we have to choose a nice angle of her, that's always subjective...).
  +
  +
Oh crud this went on really long. At any rate the major points are:
  +
  +
1 - So many people are still catching up on Season 4 that I am consciously putting off a redesign until we gear up for Season 5, around Christmas/January. The Hound may be dead "now", but taking "Season 4" as a whole unit, he's present throughout it. People looking for information about the Hound after they just watched an episode he's in would need him on the front page.
  +
  +
2 - Due to a process of elimination, I already figured out that the best choices would be to replace Joffrey with Tommen, Tywin with Myrcella, and the Hound with Yara Greyjoy. If Varys isn't in Sesaon 5 that much we'd swap him out for someone else.
  +
  +
3 - The bad quality of the Brienne image has indeed been gnawing at me, if you post up variant cropped Brienne images we can pick a better one.
  +
  +
--[[User:The Dragon Demands|The Dragon Demands]] ([[User talk:The Dragon Demands|talk]]) 03:53, July 19, 2014 (UT
  +
  +
Makes sense if we look at it from a point of view of faction leaders instead of main cast. I hadn't thought of that to be honest with Roose being the only non main cast up there, though if we throw in Tommen, Myrcella and Yara in that'll be less obvious. So I'm okay with it not being just main cast as long as it's not just one guy who doesn't fit. I still disagree about Roose though. The Bolton storyline is much smaller than say Dany's in the show and yet she is only represented by herself and they have Roose, Ramsay and Reek (the 3 Rs). Jorah is also a viewpoint character like Reek and any of his new stuff will not be in Dany's presence so I think he's a much better fit. As for faction leaders he is more a subordinate than say Mance who is one of the many Kings. Also there are more than one new characters coming (though exactly who survives the cut is yet to be seen) who would easily be better as representative to story lines than him. I won't name any for spoiler reasons but I think you can guess who I mean.
  +
  +
As for your idea of holding off a while before going to season 5 mode I can accept this. I would suggest however that the Tommen/Joffrey swap is far back enough in the season to happen now. I mean you had Joffrey's face up much higher on the page and larger when he died the moment it happened so it's hardly worth keeping that a secret anymore. Giving Tywin and the Hound some more time in the limelight now is perfectly understandable as it's still fresh for people.
  +
  +
Also yes I understand the issue with not knowing how much we'll see Varys or Olenna (and whether or not she recieves the Emmy she deserves). Personally I expect to see more Varys than Olenna in the show, even though this is opposite to the books, but who knows at this stage.
  +
  +
And sorry like I said. I'm bad with images so I really won't be much actual help here. [[User:Rachel P|<font face="Parchment" size=7 color="#D4A017">''R''</font><font face="Parchment" size=6 color="#D4A017">''achel''</font>]] [[User talk:Rachel P|<font face="Parchment" size=6 color="#D4A017">''P''</font>]] 12:48, July 19, 2014 (UTC)
  +
  +
I have a selection of already made portal pictures that I have made, you can use them for the main page if you want? http://gyazo.com/79d0a088b1d9ce8fd63429d3b19b35cb That is just an example of the ones that I have, there are more for the rest of the main characters but I couldn't fit them all into the screenshot. If you're interested just let me know who you want pictures for. :) [[User:CoyoteDork|CoyoteDork]] ([[User talk:CoyoteDork|talk]]) 17:24, July 19, 2014 (UTC)
  +
:Also if you choose to use some characters that actors aren't billed as starring, I also have some photos for a few more, such as - http://gyazo.com/6ccae2c7b7cecb3208f857936f9e8c38 Again if you're interested in using these, just let me know who you want the photos for. And if there's someone I don't have a picture for at the moment, I would be more than happy to make one. :) [[User:CoyoteDork|CoyoteDork]] ([[User talk:CoyoteDork|talk]]) 17:28, July 19, 2014 (UTC)
  +
  +
So what do you thinnk? [[User:CoyoteDork|CoyoteDork]] ([[User talk:CoyoteDork|talk]]) 14:07, July 25, 2014 (UTC)
  +
  +
I prefer some of these to the current images (assuming the red/green borders can be removed) though personally think images from the latest season would be best to keep it feeling up to date. The template is protected from non-admin edits though so its really up to The Dragon Demands. I'm just throwing in ideas. Thanks for the suggestion. [[User:Rachel P|<font face="Parchment" size=7 color="#D4A017">''R''</font><font face="Parchment" size=6 color="#D4A017">''achel''</font>]] [[User talk:Rachel P|<font face="Parchment" size=6 color="#D4A017">''P''</font>]] 04:18, July 28, 2014 (UTC)
  +
  +
'''Let me stress this again: there can only be about 25 character images on the front page portal because that's as many as will fit. If we made ones for all cast members billed as "starring" they wouldn't fit.'''
  +
  +
Second, crediting as "starring" is absolutely meaningless in a book adaptation. Shae was billed as starring in Season 4 for pay reasons, but in terms of overall impact on the storyline, Roose Bolton is a far more important character. We shouldn't blindly fit it into a TV-first mentality; we know how important Roose is, and even within the TV show ignoring the books he's more important.
  +
  +
Third...this is confusing: http://gyazo.com/6ccae2c7b7cecb3208f857936f9e8c38 Why bother to make character portal images for...Irri, Ros, or Maester Luwin, at this point?
  +
  +
There are only 25 slots, more would be far too large, we're discussing priorities among these slots.
  +
  +
As I have explained, going by the major families, few of these slots seem particularly up for grabs.
  +
  +
The current plan is:
  +
  +
*Swap out Joffrey for Tommen.
  +
*Swap out Tywin for Myrcella.
  +
*Swap out the Hound for Yara Greyjoy.
  +
  +
Varys is also sort of "on the fence" at this point. I dread if they don't use Yara prominently next season (going by the books they ''should'', she's a major character in book 4).
  +
  +
The next most prominent ones we might want to swap in are Olenna Tyrell or....I'm toying with the idea of making a group-shot image linking to "[[Sand Snakes]]", given that they seem to be prominent next season.
  +
  +
And I'd bump out Varys for Olenna automatically if Diana Rigg wins an Emmy in a few weeks :)
  +
  +
....you're right, enough time has passed that I'm going to swap out Joffrey for Tommen immediately.
  +
  +
(I'm worried I sound like I'm shouting, I'm not)
  +
  +
Well what we're discussing now is "who should the 25 front page characters be" - I hope everyone is sympathetic that this is a ''huge'' cast of characters.
  +
  +
A second, separate question is "should we add more than 25 to the front page, or would this make the front page look far too complicated?" (if we didn't, there can't be any more vertical columns because five across is as many as will fit; we ''might'' be able to add one, possibly two more lines....but I'm very hesitant because it might make it difficult to read...--[[User:The Dragon Demands|The Dragon Demands]] ([[User talk:The Dragon Demands|talk]]) 01:57, August 9, 2014 (UTC)
  +
  +
I don't think we should add more rows, but if we did, these are at the top of the list in terms of who we might want on the front page:
  +
  +
(First, we've got Tommen replacing Joffrey, Myrcella replacing Tywin, and Yara Greyjoy replacing the Hound)
  +
  +
...hmmm...
  +
  +
If Varys doesn't appear prominently in Season 5, we might replace him with a combined "Sand Snakes" icon. I don't know if we also need a Doran Martell one or if we'll do what we did with Oberyn and just make him the featured article.
  +
  +
Davos and Melisandre are good, but plausibly they can be redundant with Stannis.
  +
  +
I don't know how much Bronn will appear in Season 5. He has one really important point he takes part in but otherwise is "off screen" for much of the next book (i.e. I see him as dominating one full episode)...oh crap but there are rumors that he's going to become Jaime's new aide-de-camp in the TV version.
  +
  +
In the grand scheme of things, Missandei and Grey Worm aren't ''too'' important, Ser Barristan somewhat moreso, but all three are redundant with Daenerys, just as Davos is redundant with Stannis. We ''might'' want to put Missandei up there just so we get some representating for a black woman of color in what is otherwise mostly white men. I don't know.
  +
  +
Pycelle is nice but unlike Littlefinger or Varys he isn't his own "faction"; he's part of Team Lannister.
  +
  +
Loras gets more to do in the books at this point, just as Yara Greyjoy does....
  +
  +
Edmure and Brynden if they reappear
  +
Kevan and Lancel if they reappear
  +
  +
The five characters who rank behind the proposed 25 (if they die, etc.) would be....
  +
  +
*Olenna Tyrell (for now, but we'd remove her if she is confirmed to not return in Season 5 at all)
  +
*"Sand Snakes" - that way we can refer to many characters with one slot.
  +
*Doran Martell (or Oberyn if we do this before we get a set photo of Doran in costume)
  +
*Loras Tyrell
  +
*Bronn
  +
  +
If we added yet another row, for ''thirty-five'' characters....
  +
  +
*Davos
  +
*Melisandre
  +
*Missandei
  +
*Grey Worm
  +
*Ser Barristan
  +
  +
...though we might replace one of these with Brynden or Edmure, or perhaps replace two with Brynden AND Edmure.
  +
  +
(if Varys doesn't reappear in early Season 5 we'll replace him with Kevan Lannister...if, dear god, Kevan returns in Season 5 because he becomes more prominent after his older brother Tywin dies in the books).
  +
  +
But at the moment I am ''against'' adding more rows, I think it would be "unwieldy" to have a character table that large.--[[User:The Dragon Demands|The Dragon Demands]] ([[User talk:The Dragon Demands|talk]]) 02:16, August 9, 2014 (UTC)
  +
  +
:Tommen but not Melisandre or Davos?--[[User:Gonzalo84|Gonzalo84]] ([[User talk:Gonzalo84|talk]]) 05:54, August 9, 2014 (UTC)
  +
  +
Well Tommen ''is'' the "King on the Iron Throne" at the moment.--[[User:The Dragon Demands|The Dragon Demands]] ([[User talk:The Dragon Demands|talk]]) 16:03, August 9, 2014 (UTC)
  +
  +
I was agreeing more with CoyoteDork's choice of images rather than choice of characters. I never said anything about extra rows and agree we don't need any more. Also yes, I agree Tommen deserves a spot if we are using the faction leaders criteria as the current king on the throne . I do still feel however that under that rationale that Mance is a much better fit than Roose. The wildlings/freefolk are not represented at all otherwise and he is one of the kings, whereas the argument you've for Davos etc being redundant with other characters definitely applies to Roose/Ramsay (more so than Davos or Melisandre in my opinion) and while he may represent one part of the Lannister forces, Mance represents an entire society/army. Also personally I think that Doran as opposed to Myrcella and possibly the sand snakes works better as a representative of both the ongoing story and a faction leader. I don't care as much about about that one as I do about swapping Roose for Mance though.[[User:Rachel P|<font face="Parchment" size=7 color="#D4A017">''R''</font><font face="Parchment" size=6 color="#D4A017">''achel''</font>]] [[User talk:Rachel P|<font face="Parchment" size=6 color="#D4A017">''P''</font>]] 04:50, August 11, 2014 (UTC)
  +
  +
==Top Navigation Bar==
  +
  +
The Top Navigation Bar works like this:
  +
  +
There are three levels: Level 1, Level 2, and Level 3. It is impossible to make a fourth sub-level.
  +
  +
Level 1 things at the moment on here are "On the Wiki", "Episodes", "Characters", "Production", and "Community". Of these, we have absolutely no control over what's in "On the Wiki" - it doesn't show up in the editor (which only Admins can access) and it's controlled by Wikia. Which isn't necessarily helpful because we might want to combine some other stuff into it.
  +
  +
Level 2 things are what shows up when you hover your mouse icon over it. So for the Level 1 "Episodes", the Level 2 menu items are "Season 1", "Season 2", etc.
  +
  +
Level 3 is a drop-down menu based on things in Level 2. So you hover over "Season 1", and it shows a sub-list. The Level 2 header can be a link itself, though, so if you have the "Season 2" dropdown bar open, it's limited to ten episode slots, but you can click on the word "Season 2" to get to the Season 2 article.
  +
  +
'''We have control over at most 4 Level one menu items; each Level 2 menu can physically hold no more than 7 items -- nothing to do with word length. It's limited to 7. Then, every Level 3 dropdown menu can have no more than 10 items in it. Thus we can at most put as many as 4x7=28, 28x10 = 280 items into the Top Navigation Bar.'''
  +
  +
The Admin-level Top Navigation Bar editors also doesn't have a History tab, so you can't really see past versions to re-use an older format, but the overall page is short enough that this usually isn't a problem.
  +
  +
So what we've got now are "Episodes", "Characters", "Production", and "Community".
  +
  +
Not much is going to change with "'''Episodes'''", it's one of the major Access Points that casual readers use. So it's listed by Season. I'm going to take the "Overview" menu out though - we've got a lot of seasons, and "Overview" is a list of "Season 1", "Season 2", etc....which is redundant with how the "Season 2" dropdown menu is itself a link to Season 2.
  +
  +
In its place I want to put a link to the "Histories and Lore" animated featurettes, to make them more visible (MANY people who just casually watch the show don't know about those).
  +
  +
That would give us 5 seasons plus Histories and Lore to make six items. When we reach Season 7 (if not Season 8...) that means we won't have room for "Histories and Lore" (and if we really have Season 8, we simply won't have room for every season). So when we reach that point, we'll leave a dropdown menu for the more recent seasons like "Season 7", "Season 6", etc...but we might have to combine "Seasons 1-3" into a single dropbar, consisting of just "Season 1", "Season 2", and "Season 3", and users will then go back to those episodes from the episode listings on each of those (the actual link would hopefully go straight to the episode list section of the "Season 1" page.
  +
  +
But that's a long way off, and we'd postpone it as much as possible. Not an issue in Season 5 or Season 6.
  +
  +
And we'd of course need to make more combinations if we ever get a prequel project or something, Dunk & Egg, Dance of the Dragons, etc.
  +
  +
'''Characters''' is also probably a good setup. A lot of casual readers search by characters.
  +
  +
Limited to only 7 Level 2 headers, I went with Stark, Lannister, Baratheon, Tyrell, Greyjoy, Martell, and Targaryen.
  +
  +
Each "character group" I put there isn't strictly everyone under that family name, but "family and allies" - there aren't enough Tullys to justify using up one of the 7 Level 2 headers, so "Randyll Tarly" would go under Tyrell, "Grey Worm" under Targaryen, Areo Hotah under "Martell", etc.
  +
  +
The other factor is that we're limited to only 7 Level 2 headers, and only up to 10 Level 3 items in the drop-down menus. So I combined the Tullys into the Starks, as part of the "extended Stark family" but also Stark allies, so that's why Brynden and Edmure Tully are under the Stark menu.
  +
  +
Some of these turned out fairly well: "Stark" is Eddard and Catelyn, Eddard's 6 children to make 8, then Brynden and Edmure round it out to 10. Lannister is Tywin and his three children (4), then Jaime and Cersei's three children (7), plus Kevan and Lancel (9). It's good that Lancel will be appearing against in Season 5.
  +
  +
One snag is that allegiI wasn't really sure what to put as the tenth and last Lannister item...so I just put Ser Pounce. People like Ser Pounce. I couldn't put one of Lancel's brothers because if I put Martyn, why not Willem? And even then they're dead at this point. As for major bannermen, they didn't really set up anyone other than the Cleganes and they're both either dead or not recurring prominently.
  +
  +
...I didn't put Bronn in because his "allegiance" at this point is kind of dubious. He was working for Tyrion but he's not anymore, and in the books at least, he stops "working" for the Lannisters as a whole at that point - he married into House Stokeworth. '''Then again, given that reports say Season 5 will have Bronn continuing to work "with" Jaime on an embassy trip to Sunspear, might it make sense to include Bronn in the list?'''
  +
  +
"Baratheon" includes the three Baratheon brothers (Robert, Stannis, Renly), plus Stannis's wife and daughter (5), plus Robert's bastard son Gendry (6 - he's the only prominent and recurring bastard in the TV series version). Round that out with Melisandre, Davos, and Salladhor (Team Stannis), and Brienne of Tarth (Team Renly...I'd have put her with the Starks/Tullys if we had more room...though as a Stormlander, she sort of fits under Baratheon, and she was part of Renly's Kingsguard). So there's nothing to change there.
  +
  +
The Martell and Targaryen ones also turned out pretty well, a full list of ten, without omitting anyone too big. Martell is siblings Doran, Elia, Oberyn, then "Sand Snakes" as well as the three prominent Sand Snakes (7), Ellaria and Trystane (9), then Areo Hotah to make 10 (prominent servant/team member, prominent character, book POV character).
  +
  +
'''In the event that they later cast Arianne Martell''', we'll either take "Sand Snakes" out, or take out "Elia Martell" because she died before the series started (though she is a central influence on the actions of the surviving Martells). Not sure. And if we get both Arianne and Quentyn we might have to take out the three individual Sand Snake articles but leave in the main "Sand Snake" page. I'm not sure. But we'll decide that when they cast Arianne...and that's a problem we ''want'' to have! I doubt Quentyn will appear in the TV version though.
  +
  +
Targaryen is also fairly clear: Daenerys and Viserys, plus Rhaegar and their father the Mad King (4), plus Maester Aemon (5). Then Daenerys's major allies, including Missandei, Grey Worm, Barristan Selmy, Jorah Mormont, and Khal Drogo.
  +
  +
...anyone think we should remove Khal Drogo eventually? This listing works through Season 4, but if Hizdahr or other supporters in Slaver's Bay become more prominent, then what? It doesn't have room for Daario Naharis. By Season 5, should we swap out Jorah Mormont, and replace him with Daario? Because Jorah isn't actually "serving" her at the moment.
  +
  +
'''The two that gave me trouble were the Tyrells and Greyjoys'''. Instead of fitting everyone in, the problem with the other lists...this was too few, relative to using up one out of seven Level 2 headers.
  +
  +
They've only introduced four Tyrells in the TV series: Loras, Margaery, Olenna, Mace. With six more spots to fill, I rounded it out with Randyll Tarly and Samwell Tarly, on the logic that Randyll is a "Tyrell bannerman". Yes, Samwell is now a member of the Night's Watch, but then again, so was Jon Snow, but he's still listed under "Stark" for convenience.
  +
  +
The Greyjoys have only appeared in two out of the past twenty episodes! For a grand total of five minutes! (Not including Theon's torture scenes, which aren't really showing "The Greyjoys" as a faction).
  +
  +
So far we've only got Balon, Yara, and Theon/Reek. I tried to round this out with adding the three uncles who haven't appeared yet but who become major characters in book 4...and thus logically, SHOULD become major characters by Season 5. But both Tyrell and Greyjoy only use 6 spots each, leaving a total of 8 spots that we could fill but cannot.
  +
  +
'''Open sorting questions are:'''
  +
  +
1 - So far I've been listing "Ser Pounce" as the tenth Lannister link. Going by the books, Bronn isn't really serving the Lannisters anymore...but we know he's going to be tagging along with Jaime in Season 5. Might that justify including him?
  +
  +
2 - Should the Targaryen list remove Jorah Mormont and replace it with Daario Naharis?
  +
  +
3 - Should we eventually remove Khal Drogo from the Targaryen list, and put in a more important Season 5 character, such as Hizdahr zo Loraq? (Probably going to hold off on that until Season 5 actually airs).
  +
  +
4 - In the event that they ever cast Arianne Martell, we may need to reshuffle the Martell list in such a way that it removes either "Elia" or "Sand Snakes". But that's a problem we want to have.
  +
  +
5 - The Small Council characters didn't fit in anywhere: Varys, Littlefinger, Pycelle. Neither did Lysa, who was important in Season 4 but who's dead now. Littlefinger is even a faction unto himself. Granted, a lot of these are on the front page character boxes anyway.
  +
  +
6 - The Boltons and Freys didn't fit in anywhere.
  +
  +
So I might toy around with combining those two Tyrell and Greyjoy categories to make use of the 8 slots we're otherwise miss.--[[User:The Dragon Demands|The Dragon Demands]] ([[User talk:The Dragon Demands|talk]]) 02:01, October 18, 2014 (UTC)
  +
  +
Screw it, I'm adding Bronn in Ser Pounce's place on the Lannister tab. He was in Season 4, and we've seen that he'll be helping Jaime in Season 5.--[[User:The Dragon Demands|The Dragon Demands]] ([[User talk:The Dragon Demands|talk]]) 02:02, October 18, 2014 (UTC)
  +
  +
'''I have decided to remove the Greyjoys, and redivide the other characters.'''
  +
  +
I didn't want it to come to this, but fundamentally, unless they get around to casting Balon's three brothers, we have ONLY three major ironborn characters: Balon, Yara, and Theon....and even the HBO Viewer's Guide gets away with listing him as "Reek" under their House Bolton section.
  +
  +
So faced with the other pressures of getting "royal court" members, Boltons and Freys in there somehow....people who know who Yara Greyjoy is can find her well enough, or use the front page navigation. The VERY casual readers who have trouble finding their way around? They're more dependent on looking for articles about characters who appear more frequently.
  +
  +
So I removed the Greyjoy list, and the Tyrell list.
  +
  +
The two lists I replaced them with are "At court" and "Boltons/Freys" (which I feel are a conceptual unit; the betrayers who switched to the Lannister side at the Red Wedding).
  +
  +
So the new lists look like this:
  +
  +
*Royal court
  +
*House Baratheon of King's Landing
  +
*Small Council
  +
*Pycelle
  +
*Littlefinger
  +
*Varys
  +
*House Tyrell
  +
*Margaery
  +
*Loras
  +
*Olenna
  +
*Mace
  +
  +
*Boltons & Freys
  +
**House Bolton
  +
**Roose
  +
**Ramsay
  +
**Reek
  +
**Fat Walda
  +
**House Frey
  +
**Walder Frey
  +
**Black Walder Rivers
  +
**Lame Lothar Frey
  +
**Roslin Frey
  +
  +
The Bolton/Frey list is fairly straightforward, it includes Reek, the more prominent Freys, and I rounded it out by simply putting "House Bolton" and "House Frey" in it as list items, to navigate to. The Level 2 header needs to link to something, though (it automatically links to "Boltons & Freys" if you leave it blank)...so, I linked that to "Red Wedding" - popular, long page fairly-well developed, and it's the event where both the Boltons and Freys came to power.
  +
  +
The "Royal Court" one was a bit more tricky. Oh, I had to retitle it as "At Court" - please don't change this - because even besides the limit of seven Level 2 headers...the names in the Level 2 bar were getting so long that the ones at the end, the Targaryens, were getting cut off at the edge. '''I can read the Targaryen entries now in MY browser, but do they display well for everyone else using other screen sizes or browsers? Anyway, that's why I had to truncate it from "Royal Court" to "At Court".
  +
  +
...okay, another quick fix is that I switched "Martell" and "Targaryen" so now Martell is the right-most. Martell names tend to be slightly shorter than Targaryen names, I hope that helps (actually, GRRM intentionally made Targaryen names long and complicated - the Valyrians were the powerful, refined, imperial culture. First Men names are intentionally simple: "Stark", "Jon", etc. Andal names like "Loras Tyrell" are kind of in-between).
  +
  +
"At Court" is actually a list of the Small Council, and House Tyrell. Everyone else already fits under "House Lannister" (the two are kind of synonymous at the moment). The only exception is that the very first one listed is "House Baratheon of King's Landing"...and I have the title itself link to "Red Keep".
  +
  +
So again, like Boltons and Freys, I rounded out the list by making what ''would'' be the header on the shorter lists just the top entry: "Small Council" followed by Pycelle, Littlefinger, and Varys, then "House Tyrell", followed by the four main Tyrell characters. Yeah, I know that Littlefinger and Varys aren't really at court anymore, but they're major characters, and it's sort of the best place that fit. They are "of" the royal court, they ''were'' there fore many years, etc. Also considering the wiki as a whole, going through past seasons. Generally I think that works.
  +
  +
...Maybe instead of linking to "Red Keep" it can link to "House Baratheon of King's Landing", freeing up another slot. But who else is there? Qyburn? Okay, unless there are objections, I'll make "At Court" link to House Baratheon of King's Landing, and put "Qyburn" in that slot.
  +
  +
Otherwise we lost a link to "House Greyjoy", "Balon Greyjoy", and "Yara Greyjoy" but...the really casual readers who rely only on the Top Bar really wouldn't be looking for them. The Top Bar is for browsing-navigation, not people who know what they're looking for. And they sadly haven't used the Greyjoys enough. We can update this in Season 5 if things change.
  +
  +
So, thoughts on this? Suggestions?--[[User:The Dragon Demands|The Dragon Demands]] ([[User talk:The Dragon Demands|talk]]) 03:25, October 18, 2014 (UTC)
  +
  +
==Top Navigation Bar - Production==
  +
  +
So of the four Level 1 Top Bar items we have control over, "Episodes" and "Characters" are pretty much in place. The next one I set up is "Production".
  +
  +
It currently only has ''six'' Level 2 sub-menus, when it can sustain up to ''seven'', but I'm not sure what else to add.
  +
  +
The Level 2 menus I put in are Writers, Directors, Crew by Department, Actors, and "Production topics". The sixth one I added in was "Merchandise" -- not exactly a "Production" topic, but it is also "out of universe"..."Merchandise" doesn't really fit in "Episodes" or "Characters",
  +
  +
"Writers" was pretty easy, there have only been seven writers on the show: Martin, Benioff, Weiss, Espenson (Season 1), Taylor (Season 2-3), Cogman, and Hill (starting in Season 5, but an assistant before that and writer of "Histories and Lore").
  +
  +
"Directors" was a bit more difficult because there have been more than 10 directors. So I put in a mix of A - Directors who will be in Season 5, B - prominent past directors (i.e. Michelle MacLaren)....hmmm...maybe I can use the extra seventh slot to just divide "Directors" into two big sections.
  +
  +
"Actors" was a bit hard but I picked the ones I figure people are most likely to search for, overlapping with those we have developed the most. So it's: Dinklage, Harington, Clarke, Williams, Turner, Headey, Coster-Waldau, Dormer, Christie, and Leslie. Didn't have enough space for Kristian Nairn, but he's not even going to be back next season.
  +
  +
The next one is "Crew by Department", which is all of the other major production team members besides writers and directors: stuff like Michele Clapton (Costume designers), Gemma Jackson and Deborah Riley (Set Design), David Peterson (Languages), etc. etc. Pretty much managed to fit all of the major ones onto one list.
  +
  +
After that I put "Production Topics" - other behind-the-scenes production-related articles that didn't fit elsewhere: Game of Thrones (TV series), Dunk & Egg prequel, Production Timeline, Title sequence, Difference between books and TV series (which is itself a menu page directing to the series of "Differences" pages), Pronunciation guide, Sexposition. Then "Soundtracks" and "Video effects production companies", which actually link to the category pages for those.
  +
  +
Currently there are only ''nine'' things in "Production Topics" though, not sure what could be put as a tenth thing.
  +
  +
And then as I said I put a Level 2 link to "Merchandise" just because there was space, Production is also "out of universe", and because Merchandise certainly didn't fit elsewhere.
  +
  +
...hmm...maybe I should make two Level 2 Director menus and just split them in half...--[[User:The Dragon Demands|The Dragon Demands]] ([[User talk:The Dragon Demands|talk]]) 18:51, October 18, 2014 (UTC)
  +
  +
:Alright, done. Had to cut the names down to "Crew" and "Production" (for "Production topics") to get them all to fit on the screen (you're limited to seven Level 2 subheaders, but if they're all really longs names it can't display).--[[User:The Dragon Demands|The Dragon Demands]] ([[User talk:The Dragon Demands|talk]]) 23:55, October 18, 2014 (UTC)
  +
  +
==Top Navigation Bar - Community==
  +
  +
...does ''anyone'' use this thing? It's the only other Level 1 Nav Bar item we're allowed to have...and it's kind of going to waste.
  +
  +
Level 2 headers include: Basic Information, Community Forum, Policies - Parent Page, the drop-down menu for "Help Pages", and Affiliates.
  +
  +
The only Level 3 dropdown menu is the "Help Pages" list, which is actually just auto-generated from linking to the "Help" category: "Index", "Help Desk", "Overview Categories", "Instruction: Images", and the "Welcome" template. The Forum actually has two subdivisions: "Watercooler" is what we think of as "The Forum" -- we use it infrequently enough that we didn't really need another sub-forum. The other Forum subdivision is actually "Help Desk" but...it's only had four threads in the past two years. It's redundant, anyone looking for help usually just posts to the Forum anyway (or Admin talk page). "Index" is also just the "Forum index", showing "Watercooler" and "Help Desk".
  +
  +
So what's left on Level 3? "Overview Categories", "Instruction-Images", and the "Welcome" template.
  +
  +
'''...No one really uses these for Navigation (at least I think they don't), and these last three we could just put into the automated Welcome message (new accounts will see "This is how images work", the categories, etc. etc.)
  +
  +
....and the same could be said for "Policies" as well as "Basic information". All of this could be in the Welcome message, or, quickly listed in the Community messages displayed on the "Recent changes" page.
  +
  +
...the only thing in the entire Level one "Community" Navigation tab that we actually use is "Community Forum" (which links to the "Watercooler" subforum...which is really the only subforum). That an "Affiliates" -- I'm not sure where else to put that.
  +
  +
So the only two things we have a great need to salvage as menu items are a Forum link and Affiliates. Well...we could also put those in the "Community messages" on the "Recent changes" page.
  +
  +
...a Level 1 menu tab can have 7 Level 2 tabs, each with a dropdown menu containing 10 items each....that's potentially '''*70 menu links*''' which are sort of going to waste, for only 2 we would really use now (plus "Help" stuff which sort of fits in a Welcome message anyway).
  +
  +
'''So as an experiment, I'm going to try replacing the "Community" tab with a "Culture & Society" tab...which is basically the specific pages which weren't "Episodes" or "Characters" -- thematic stuff.'''
  +
  +
We usually notice new Forum posts in "recent changes" anyway. We could ask the Wikia Staffers to play around with the CSS code eventually to add a "Forum" ink in the open slot under "On the Wiki". Not sure how Affiliates works.
  +
  +
But again...basically weighing maybe 2 links we actually use with ''potentially Seventy''.--[[User:The Dragon Demands|The Dragon Demands]] ([[User talk:The Dragon Demands|talk]]) 02:12, October 19, 2014 (UTC)
  +
  +
  +
==Top Navigation Bar - Culture & Society==
  +
  +
Okay, I've removed the old "Community" tab which we weren't really using, and transferred the two or three links of note into the "Community Messages" page which shows up in "Recent changes".
  +
  +
In its place, I have constructed a new "Culture & Society" Level 1 menu tab.
  +
  +
The seven Level 2 menus it contains are: Timeline, Organizations, Religions, Social groups, Laws & Customs, Peoples in Westeros, and Peoples in Essos.
  +
  +
...now to make it all fit on-screen, I had to shorten the names to "Groups", "Customs", "Westeros", and "Essos", but I think the meanings are still fairly obvious.
  +
  +
"Customs" (Laws & Customs) is basically thematic stuff that didn't fit in the other categories: Currency, Food & Drink, Languages, etc.
  +
  +
I also moved "Production" to the right-most end, because it's "out of universe" while "Culture & Society" has more to do with the two other "In-universe" things, Episodes and Characters.
  +
  +
Does everyone think this setup is good?
  +
  +
Is it displaying well on other people's web browsers, without getting cut off?
  +
  +
Also, were there any typos I made which make the links not work? (I had to fix "Guest Right" to "Guest right" lowercase, the title is case-sensitive).--[[User:The Dragon Demands|The Dragon Demands]] ([[User talk:The Dragon Demands|talk]]) 20:49, October 19, 2014 (UTC)

Latest revision as of 20:50, October 19, 2014

Use this page to discuss design and content changes to the main page. For general wiki discussion, please visit the Community Portal or Forums.

Welcome to the Game of Thrones Wiki for the HBO television series of the same name. This Wiki is intended to act as a guide to the television series, not as a general resource for the novels. Those looking for a guide to the book series are referred to the Wiki of Ice and Fire maintained by the Westeros.org team, or the considerably less-developed Song of Ice and Fire Wikia.

This Wiki is based on the premise that the Game of Thrones television series, despite apparently being a faithful adaptation of the books, will likely diverge from the novels in key areas, and indeed already has done so through the addition of new scenes and dialogue in the pilot, the removal of some minor characters and actors varying from the detail of the descriptions in the novels. For this reason pages should only be started about subjects once it is known they will be in the TV series. For example, whilst it is highly probable that the castle of Storm's End will appear in the TV series, we have not heard anything about it so far in relation to the TV series, so starting a page about it at this time would not be appropriate. On the other hand, we know that Winterfell appears as filming has already taken place there. However, the appearance, layout and history of the TV version of Winterfell will likely be different to that established in the books, and information from the books should not be used to describe the TV version of Winterfell.

That said, the presence of a 'How the TV series differs from the books' section in the relevant articles is appopriate, but only if spoilers are avoided.

As the television series will not debut until early 2011, this means that current articles will largely be broad articles about the series itself, background information on actors and behind the scenes personnel, and notes on filming locations and dates.--Werthead 14:16, June 24, 2010 (UTC)

To clarify article and link-creation policy, we still don't know that everything in the books will be in the TV series. In fact, we know that Castle Darry has already been removed from the series (all the action that takes place there has been moved to either the Crossroads Inn or to Tywin's war camp), so there's no guarantee that places like Seagard, Stone Hedge etc will be mentioned in the show (and thus shouldn't be linked or covered on the wiki). At the same time, mentioning a unique place name and leaving it unlinked may be confusing. One possible answer would be to link those articles to the respective entry on the Wiki of Ice and Fire instead, but this would involve putting a spoiler warning after every such link, which could be tedious and messy. Thoughts?--Werthead 11:33, February 20, 2011 (UTC)

Fourth slider slot Edit

Xean added a link to the book wiki in the fourth slot in the slider. I don't think we should be linking to that (not that much content and possible *major* spoilers), but I do agree that the slider looks wierd with the fourth slot empty.


Any ideas on what else we could fill it with? TOR 18:13, February 7, 2011 (UTC)

Agreed. And the book Wikia is pretty dead now, if they're going to link to a book one, it should be to the Wiki of Ice and Fire hosted by the Westeros.org crew. My rec would be to a map of Westeros and a link on geography, exploring the Seven Kingdoms, that sort of thing :-) Great work from all the newcomers, by the way, it was getting lonely in here :-) Nice to have a new logo (from the Cyanide computer game, right?) as well, although we should replace it with the TV series logo as soon as HBO settle on a final version --Werthead 13:37, February 9, 2011 (UTC)
Maybe make the fourth slide about the Cyanide game? I think it's worth covering on this wiki as well (not strictly connected to the show, but it's also out of AWoIaF's scope, and it will likely be heavily targeted at the show's viewers). Ausir(talk) 16:37, February 16, 2011 (UTC)
My idea behind the TV wiki was that we'd cover only things directly related to the TV series, such as merchandise bearing the TV GoT and HBO logos. The computer game is not based on the HBO series, something I expect will be made clearer as we get closer to the game coming out (a bit like the time when there was LORD OF THE RINGS games coming out based separately on the books and the movies). In fact, if the TV series is a hit I suspect HBO will look at licensing out their own computer game based on the TV show. AWoIaF would be the correct venue for info on it, but they haven't done much in the way of creating pages based on merchandising yet. We could possibly mention it on a subsection of the book page, mentioning merchandising of various kinds, but I don't think it should get its own page as it is not affiliated directly with HBO (in fact, I wouldn't be surprised if people at HBO were debating asking them to change the name).--Werthead 19:29, February 16, 2011 (UTC)
Well, I think it would make sense to expand this wiki's scope also to other licensed properties, not just the show or HBO-affiliated ones. I doubt that the AWoIaF community will have much interest in giving much of a focus to anything but the books themselves. But if you think it's a bad idea, I suppose we could set up a separate wiki for them. And I don't really see how HBO could force them to change the name - Martin holds the rights to that, and I doubt any of the non-HBO licensed products, like the board game, the computer game, the card game, etc. will be renamed (and they can be distinguished by "A Game of Thrones" vs. "Game of Thrones"). Ausir(talk) 22:38, February 16, 2011 (UTC)
I'll check with Ran to see what they want to do about pages on merchandising. If they're not keen on it, maybe we could do something here then ;-) --Werthead 15:25, February 19, 2011 (UTC)
According to Ran, the WoIaF is going to be handling merchandising, they just haven't gotten round to it yet. --Werthead 11:33, February 20, 2011 (UTC)
I was actually thinking of repurposing the Ice and Fire wiki at Wikia as a wiki focused mainly on merchandising, video games, etc. since it clearly has no chance at competing with AWoIaF as a wiki focused on the books. By the way, would AWoIaF be open to a deeper partnership with this wiki, with e.g. links to each other on the main page, and on each character page etc. ("read more about Ned Stark in the TV series/in the books" links at the end of each article)? Ausir(talk) 22:16, February 21, 2011 (UTC)
That is an excellent suggestion. We could keep the book pages (which already have info on different editions) but most of the character/house ones could go, or alternatively we could keep them with notes on how they are depicted in different media. I've already spoken to Ran about partnering AWoIaF and the GoT one and that's something in the works. Even better, I've been contacted by HBO directly and they may be interested in involving us in the marketing for the TV series in some manner. It also means we have a direct line to check up on issues. For example, I'm going to ask if we can use the screencaps that various fansites have taken from the trailers and teasers, as they would radically expand the number of photos on the wiki.--Werthead 09:48, February 22, 2011 (UTC)

Spellchecker testing works Edit

You might have noticed already that we now have spellchecker functionality in the visual editor. This is an exclusive test, run on only a few wikis. Hope you like it! This is still in beta, so if you encounter any problems or issues with it, please let me know. Safe typing! TOR 13:03, February 17, 2011 (UTC)


You need to use proper grammar:

War of the Five Kings– Season 2 is underway and war ravages the Seven Kingdoms! Who are the five kings involved? What do we know about their forces? Read our article to find out more about the conflict.Glassonion0

Thank you for pointing out my error, I have corrected it.--Opark 77 14:01, May 15, 2012 (UTC)
Thank you for not being a Jack Ass about it, the Star Trek Wiki people are rude.Glassonion0

Screencaps Edit

I have received permission via telephone call from HBO Marketing to use screencaps from the trailers, teasers and other released media to illustrate articles on the wiki. Screencaps can be used under the following restrictions: we don't go overboard with them (i.e. one per article, more only if necessary to illustrate different facets of the article), we don't use ones that are major spoilers for events later in the series (i.e. we don't use the screencaps of the Three-Eyed Crow until it's appeared on-screen) and we emphasise on the upload pages that all screencaps are HBO copyright. Also, whilst Marketing are okay with us using them, HBO Legal may have a different opinion and we must be willing to remove any or all screencaps at any time (but since HBO Legal are okay with the screencaps on the numerous other HBO Wikis, this is a highly unlikely eventuality). Ran at Westeros.org has also given us permission to use the screencaps that they take and put up on their GoT page, and we should acknowledge that as well. Beyond that we should be good to go :-) --Werthead 15:02, March 2, 2011 (UTC)

Awesome! Great job, Werthead! --TOR@Wikia 01:11, March 3, 2011 (UTC)
Waiting for Westeros's screencaps of the latest video. We can add images of the Wall, but I doubt the very brief image of the Other will be usable (plus it's kind of spoilery). Any thoughts on the logo? Our current one is good, but I was thinking of using the TV show's one. However, I note that other HBO Wikis don't use them (TRUE BLOOD deliberately uses another one), whilst other TV show wikis (like Memory Alpha for STAR TREK) do. Any preference?--Werthead 21:37, March 4, 2011 (UTC)

Video EditsEdit

Replaced the 'First Full Trailer' with the official HBO version, which is higher in quality. Also put it on the front page, thought the YouTube still of Catelyn isn't great. :-) --Werthead 21:37, March 4, 2011 (UTC)

RSS FeedEdit

What's wrong with the RSS feed on the front page? The page keep says it can't load it, but the feed is valid. I don't know the syntax of the RSS feed, if there is a bug there. --Starhop 22:13, May 5, 2011 (UTC)

Seems to be working fine now, don't know if someone else fixed it. I am thinking we need to change the RSS feed, maybe to a dedicated news reel with posts from Westeros.org's TV page and maybe Winter is Coming's entries. We're picking up a lot of tangential stories on the front page feed which don't have much to do with the TV show. Unfortunately, I don't know anything at all about changing RSS feeds to do that.--Werthead 14:57, May 7, 2011 (UTC)

New logo needed Edit

We've been using the Game of Thrones: Genesis logo for a while now, which was okay as a placeholder whilst HBO had not revealed the final logo for the TV series. However, using this logo now risks confusion between the TV series and the computer game, and of course the computer game logo is copyrighted by Cyanide and we do not have permission to use it. On the other hand, we do have permission from HBO to use screencaps and promo images, so using the TV logo should also be fine. I'll see if I can find a good version of it.--Werthead 15:01, May 7, 2011 (UTC)

Right, I have a possible good new logo uploaded at Wiki.png, but I can't update the current logo which is set to Wiki-wordmark.png, not sure what the issue is there. Any ideas?--Werthead 15:36, May 7, 2011 (UTC)
We have already found a new logo. So new people reading this should disregard what is being written. Cheers LordofOnions (Talk) 22:50, August 6, 2011 (UTC)

House Greyjoy in the slider Edit

With Season 3 upon us I believe we should replace House Greyjoy, which had a bigger role in Season 2, with Mance Rayder, who will have a huge role after two seasons of being just mentioned.--Gonzalo84 (talk) 16:21, March 7, 2013 (UTC)

Sure! :) Just put Mance in the Greyjoy's spot. QueenBuffy35 Crown New Red 16:25, March 7, 2013 (UTC)
I concur: they're going to take a backseat until season 4-ish, when they introduce Theon and Yara's uncles.--The Dragon Demands (talk) 19:49, March 7, 2013 (UTC)

Spoiler! Edit

Some admin please speedy-delete the recently uploaded named image of a certain STILL UNNAMED character! -- SaganamiFan (talk) 21:07, June 4, 2013 (UTC)

Update front page character boxesEdit

I think we need to update the front page character boxes: the four by four, sixteen characters presented as front page portals. We must remember that while we regular editors know where everything is, casual new readers often access most things on the wiki by randomly clicking on shiny things on the front page about major characters.

Out of the sixteen, there are a few locks:

  • Ned Stark's surviving children - 4 boxes (Sansa, Arya, Jon, Bran (Rickon doesn't get a slot))
  • The core Lannisters - 5 boxes (Tywin, Cersei, Jaime, Tyrion, Joffrey)
  • Daenerys Targaryen - carrying the entire Essos storyline

So those are 10 out of 16 which right away I don't think anyone will disagree with.

Next, while not a complete lock, I'm fairly certain that we should include Stannis (standing in for his associated characters and subplot too), as well as Littlefinger and Varys.

These 13 characters are already on the front page.

What's at issue is the next three spots, which are currently:

  • Theon
  • Melisandre
  • Sandor "The Hound" Clegane

I've seen other news sites trying to rank characters based on the raw number of episodes they appear in: this is utterly absurd, given that certain important characters may appear in few yet pivotal scenes, while others may only appear as accessories of other characters (Bronn technically appears in most episodes Tyrion does). Moreover I thought that statistical study was really interesting in which someone figured out what percentage of characters each character spoke in Season 3 - Bronn actually had a line or two more than Catelyn Stark.

So the choice should be based on "who is important in the storyline", which will be in part based on what the spoiled know will be happening this season based on the books (as it always is).

We should probably pick from people actually listed as "main cast" in Season 4, not "recurring".

Well, this was a mouthful. Now we come to The Point:

Sandor Clegane is an important character, but in terms of "geo-politics" in a continent spanning war, he isn't Tywin or Stannis. Then again Balon Greyjoy shouldn't get a slot either due to his rare appearance. But Sandor is so closely tied to other storylines (Joffrey before, Arya now) that I really don't think he needs his own slot.

I'm not sure about Melisandre - she *is* important, but also a bit redundant with Stannis.

I'm not really sure what to do with Theon - he *is* important, even more than Melisandre (given that he doesn't overlap with someone, as she does Stannis). But we don't know how much screentime he'll have. Part of this decision should be based on screentime.

So my suggestion is that at the very least, we should replace The Hound with Margaery Tyrell, due to her importance in the storyline, significant scenes, and representation of an entire political faction (House Tyrell) in the wider war. Does anyone think Melisandre or Theon should be replaced with someone else?--The Dragon Demands (talk) 05:02, February 2, 2014 (UTC)

Okay I've had time to think on this:

Theon should stay on the front page, Margaery Tyrell should replace Sandor Clegane as I said, but also, I think Brienne of Tarth should replace Melisandre.

Theon should stay on the front page -- He is a major character and remains a major character. The only reason we *might* want to leave him out is if he doesn't have a lot of screentime - similar to how Jaime Lannister was back-burnered in book/season 2. He disappears for books 3 and 4, presumed dead, but then book 5 reveals that he was kept prisoner by Ramsay and horrifically tortured (the TV show chose to present this in the chronological order that it happened). However, judging from the trailers they might be moving up some of Theon's material from Book 5 - or if nothing else will apparently show more of his torture at the hands of Ramsay (Theon is *literally unrecognizable* by the end, even people who knew him well). But if Theon will have prominent screentime he should stay.

The best way to define the major characters is generally those who were POV narrators in the books. Sandor was never a POV narrator (Melisandre did later narrate a chapter or two but not that much). The different POV narrations show the different story threads from different angles (i.e. Sansa shows what's happening in King's Landing, Theon shows what's happening in Winterfell, etc.). So it serves as a starting point for readers to branch off from.

Keeping this in mind, I still think that Margaery Tyrell should replace Sandor Clegane. Margaery actually isn't a POV narrator but she is much more important in the story, shows entirely different and major plot threads - while Sandor is either in Sansa or Arya's POV narrations.

Melisandre is fairly important, but her storyline will mostly overlap with Stannis's, which he already covers on the front page.

Meanwhile, Brienne of Tarth became a POV narrator starting at this point in the books, and her storyline goes in entirely separate directions (she reached King's Landing as promised but the Starks are dead including Catelyn so her prisoner exchange is a moot point, and her native Stormlands have mostly bent the knee to the Lannisters post-Blackwater).

Interestingly, trailers suggest that they'll *invent* some scenes for Brienne with the Tyrells - I assume having them argue about what all of the Renly supporters are doing now that he has died - and why the Tyrells are supporting the Lannisters now. Pointing out that, like Brienne, they'd never support Stannis (he'd never forgive them for supporting Renly) so they're kind of stuck - but the Tyrells don't exactly *like* the Lannisters either. Good politics stuff - too soon they forget that Brienne is actually the heir to a noble House from the Stormlands (though I don't think the Tarths are that powerful). It also helps that Brienne of Tarth is a fairly popular character, whome TV viewers will want to search for first.

So the other 13 were mostly locks, Theon I only hesitated on because I thought he might have reduced screentime but apparently he doesn't. Meanwhile, I think Sandor Clegane and Melisandre are fairly redundant, while Margaery Tyrell and Brienne of Tarth are more important and should be given their spots on the front page portal.--The Dragon Demands (talk) 18:13, February 3, 2014 (UTC)

We're going to leave the character portal as it is until Season 5 starts to gear up.

Looking ahead, out of 25 available slots, we'll be removing the dead characters Tywin and Joffrey, and also Sandor Clegane (whose status is unconfirmed, but who hasn't reappeared in the books since).

I anticipate no major changeups. The five remaining Stark children (including Jon, but minus Rickon) plus Samwell Tarly make six. Cersei, Jaime, and Tyrion make nine. Margaery, Stannis, Daenerys, and Brienne will also remain (due to being viewpoint characters for their respective subplots/factions). This brings us up to 13. Also keep Roose/Ramsay/Reek to make 16.

Joffrey's slot will be replaced by Tommen, that seems obvious. Leaving us with TWO free slots.

Also I think Littlefinger should stay (he'll probably appear in Sansa scenes at the Eyrie)....but I don't know if Varys will be reappearing in Season 5 or not (not much spoilers to say that he's not present "on page" for much of the next book, but people get letters or messages from him so his "presence" is felt, and the TV series might just decide to actually show what he was doing "offscreen", just as it gave Loras and Renly stuff which was "off screen" in the books)....tell you what: Varys is important enough as a "faction" unto himself that we'll leave him in his front page slot, but if it turns out that he doesn't appear in the first couple of Season 5 episodes we'll shuffle him out (possibly to be shuffled back later).

So two clearly free slots...

The reason I don't want to put Davos or Melisandre in is because they're basically redundant with Stannis. They're part of the Stannis subplot (similarly, Bran Stark's companions are redundant with Bran).

Ah! I know. If the books are any guide, the next book shifts a lot of focus on the internal politics of Dorne and the Iron Islands (and the Greyjoys REALLY got shorted in Season 4). So we'll update it to have Yara Greyjoy take one slot.

Meanwhile, for our "viewpoint Dorne" character I'd like to put Myrcella...tying in with the fact that the character portal loosely focuses on "Stark vs Lannister" as the core dynamic (or "Lannisters vs their clear enemies, Stark/Baratheon). And they said they're going to give a lot of screentime to Myrcella next season (again, much like Renly/Loras, it's stated that she's doing a lot of stuff "off screen" in the Dorne chapters, which are told from Arianne Martell's perspective). But they want to focus on the Myrcella/Trystane romance, which is good.

So the plan is, we keep the character portal as it is, until Februaryish when the first trailer for Season 5 comes out. Then we:

  • Swap out Joffrey for Tommen.
  • Swap out Tywin for Myrcella.
  • Swap out the Hound for Yara Greyjoy.

And we'll leave Varys in until the first episode or two of Season 5, and see if he's actually in it that much.--The Dragon Demands (talk) 01:31, July 2, 2014 (UTC)

Season 4 Wiki skinEdit

We will soon have to choose a new skin for the wiki in Season 4. In Season 2 we used the promotional image of someone grasping the crown (I miss that one). In Season 3 we used the promotional images of everyone's faces - which were fun but now look like heads staring at me - well, characters I like, but it looks weird for people looking over my shoulder (haha).

So what should the Season 4 skin be? Some may argue for that dragon shadow poster thing but I don't think it's distinct enough.

I think it might be good to use images from the Red Wedding - specifically, repeating that image of the burning Stark banner: http://gameofthrones.wikia.com/wiki/File:Mhysa_burning_stark_banner.png (not necessarily this exact screenshot of it). I really liked the color palette in Season 2 of the hand reaching for a crown on a burning field. And I guess the thing I didn't like about the Season 3 ones is how blue they are - a very cold color palette. Yes, I know "Ice and Fire". But I think a burning Stark banner will emphasize how much chaos and destruction is going on.

Well, that's my opinion.--The Dragon Demands (talk) 05:08, February 2, 2014 (UTC)

I just read this, and I support adding a burning Stark banner to the wiki skin, which is an brilliant idea The Dragon. If I may ask, have you progressed anywhere with this future skin for the wiki? Just curious! :) – The Snow Prince (talk) 20:31, May 12, 2014 (UTC)

...I have no experience with changing wiki skins. That's why I was asking.

But we were discussing making a new skin for a new season before Season 4 began...now Season 4 is over and we're still stuck with the damned fish-heads staring at me from Season 3. What progress is being made on this?--The Dragon Demands (talk) 15:06, June 30, 2014 (UTC)

Bran Edit

Er... some genius managed to destroy the Bran Stark article by turning it into a redirect on itself... -- SaganamiFan (talk) 13:13, April 7, 2014 (UTC)

It's been fixed.--The-Boy 13:18, April 7, 2014 (UTC)


My two cents: maybe instead of changing out the background each new season, we could decide on a permanent background image? Maybe the Iron Throne itself, as the series is "Game of Thrones". DRAEVAN13 16:16, August 6, 2014 (UTC)

Okay, I tried loading a placeholder new background I made up...and it instantly reverts back to the default, within a few seconds. When you're in "Theme designer" mode, the history of the past 10 revisions says an IP address automatically reverted my new upload seconds after I made it. Why?

This update should have happened at the beginning of Season 4 but we're still using the skin from Season 3. I'm not the best with design, but I tried to load up SOME form of a background just to get away from the crappy fish-eyed posters staring dead at us.--The Dragon Demands (talk) 03:30, August 7, 2014 (UTC)

RedesignEdit

I'm making an overhaul of the front page; before the Season 4 premiere I moved things around a bit on the front page for ease of access.

Now, I have set up collapsible menus for major topics like "Noble Houses" or "Organizations".

I've had some library studies training, and the big point you have to remember is "casual fans don't even know what they're looking for" and know less than we do.

So we know where the "Kingsguard" page is, but unless they new the proper name and put it in a search engine, they wouldn't know how to find it through general browsing.

Also we need to support new fans who just come on here to browse, without even a specific topic to look up.

Basically they're called "access points" -- the names which TV-first viewers will try to look up to find information. So far we've been mostly using the Episode Guide as the main access point: people come on here, read an episode guide, and clink on the internal links. Also on the front page our main access points have been the Character pages (people look up "Arya Stark", "Tyrion Lannister", "Jon Snow", etc.) - We needed more "access points" on the front page itself, i.e. a menu for "Culture and Society" so people will know we even have a page on "Heraldry" or "Knighthood".

I've also increased the number of characters on the front page menu from 16 to 25.

Given that the season has already started I didn't have time to make images customed to fit the menu screen, so some of them are a bit oddly shaped. The Boy Who Cried Direwolf was already helping out with the Bolton character images. But the important thing was to have the menus made; we can tweak and refine the images as we go.

I'll continue to refine the new front page menus.--The Dragon Demands (talk) 15:43, April 16, 2014 (UTC)

It looks fantastic. I can always help out with reconfiguring the portal images.--The-Boy 16:07, April 16, 2014 (UTC)

Navigation bar redesignEdit

The Navigation Bar hasn't been significantly updated in two years, since inactive Admin KarinS put in a basic setup.

I have redesigned the navigation bar from scratch.

The old setup had this layout for the "Characters" navigation tab:

http://gameofthrones.wikia.com/wiki/MediaWiki:Wiki-navigation?oldid=12950

Category:Characters | Characters Category:Characters | All characters Category:Status: Alive | Characters, alive Category:Status: Dead | Characters, dead Category:Status: Unsure | Characters, status uncertain Category:Actor | Actors Category:Actor | All actors Category:Status: Active | Actors, active Category:Status: Not hired | Actors, not hired Category:Status: Role ended | Actors, role ended

This was absurd.

Who would come onto this wiki and attempt to navigate through the characters on the basis of who is dead and who is alive? Or "uncertain"? Making the actor navigation copy this, based on "role ended" or "active", only compounded the problem.

The thought just occurred to me that I've been staring at this bizarre navigation system for two years and never thought to ask about it.

I have completely rebuilt this into a new setup based on House affiliation: Stark-Tully, Lannister, Tyrell, Targaryen, etc. There was limited space so I couldn't fit in more than seven groups....but I think this is far superior to what we've had until now.

Meanwhile, I completely renamed the "Actors" tab as "Production", and gutted it. It is impossible with limited nav bar space to list all actors in a meaningful way, and it was silly to list them based on "active" or "Role ended". Now, "actors" is only one link in the production tab, the others being changed to things like "Writers" and "Directors", plus direct links to major ones like "Gemma Jackson"/"Deborah Riley", and Michele Clapton.

Moreover, I think many of you have seen the complaints about the navigation setup for episodes. They used to be based simply on "Category - Season 1" ...which presents a random shuffle of the episodes.

I think you've all seen complaints about this.

Anyway the thought struck me that there's no...reason, to use a random shuffle "category" link when there are only ten episodes in a season. So I redesigned it as a numbered list with redirects to the correct episodes pages. Hopefully this will help things run smoother.

These are just the nav bar on the top of every page, though; I've also been fine tuning the new expandable nav box system on the front page. --The Dragon Demands (talk) 04:15, May 4, 2014 (UTC)


Should we change pictures of characters in portal? New poll could also be useful, like something like Who will win Tyrion's trial, Oberyn Martell or ser Gregor Clegane. --Gladiatus (talk) 08:24, May 25, 2014 (UTC)

Jaime's picture Edit

Jaime Lannister isn't rocking the beard or dirty hair anymore. Is it time that his picture be changed on here?

--Iron Bank (talk) 17:05, June 19, 2014 (UTC)

"Episodes" drop-down menu Edit

Because it is the "Episodes" drop-down menu, shouldn't Second Sons, The Bear and the Maiden Fare, and The Rains of Castamere be linked directly to their respective Episode page rather than the disambiguation page?  --Iron Bank (talk) 19:35, June 27, 2014 (UTC)

Absolutely. Sorry, I forgot about disambiguation pages when I redesigned the navigation bar during Season 4.--The Dragon Demands (talk) 20:10, June 27, 2014 (UTC)
You can only put 10 items in a list, so for the "characters" dropdown lists, I tried to fill them in. It's by faction, not family, so it includes "Baratheon and Baratheon retainers" you see. "Stark" is actually "Stark-Tully" (whole names don't always fit in the navbar itself). The Starks and Tullys were pretty obvious (Eddard and Catelyn, plus six children = 8, plus Edmure and Brynden = 10). Lannister was also obvious (Tywin, Tywin's three children, Cersei's three children = 7. Plus Kevan and Lancel, the only other blood Lannisters seen on the show, gives us 9. Used to just cut off at "Martyn" before I realized I only had room for one more...so I figured, "might as well put Ser Pounce" (he's popular and people would look for his page). Baratheon included the three brothers Robert, Stannis, Renly. Plus Gendry gives 4. Brienne is a major character from the Stormlands and served Renly so she's in there to make 5. Plus Selyse and Shireen to round out the living ones, core remaining family with Stannis, gives us seven. So then I added Davos, Salladhor, and Melisandre to round out Stannis's retainers. Targaryen also mostly obvious: Daenerys, Viserys, Mad King Aerys II, Maester Aemon, Khal Drogo = 5. Rhaegar was important enough to also put in there to make 6. Round it out with Daenerys's major retainers: Jorah, Bartistan, Missandei, Grey Worm. Didn't have enough room for Daario, but he's the most recent one, and I kind of think Missandei and Grey Worm need more attention. I added the currently known Greyjoys, Martells, and Tyrells, but they each fell short of 10, but that's what we have.--The Dragon Demands (talk) 02:54, June 28, 2014 (UTC)

"Actors" menuEdit

As I've said the old navigation bar was bizarre, using up space on nav icons for "actors, current", "actors, role ended", "actors, uncertain" etc.

I shorted this to just one icon for "All actors" which takes you to the category page. But the way it works is that it includes a dropdown menu...of what I thought would be a random collection of actors every time, but in fact were always the same ones. I've now realized this was also bizarre because it kept showing "Tamzin Merchant" which isn't really relevant at this point.

The problem is that if it's not showing random actors each time (and that wasn't very useful either), the dropdown menus can only list a maximum of ten entries.

So I decided to list the actor pages people are most likely to be looking for, coming here to read (most of our actor articles aren't very substantive, except for a few key cast members anyway).

So the short list I made up is this:

  • Peter Dinklage
  • Kit Harington
  • Emilia Clarke
  • Maisie Williams
  • Sophie Turner
  • Lena Headey
  • Nikolaj Coster-Waldau
  • Natalie Dormer

I think these are the major ones most people want to look up, and fairly obvious. Problem is that it was only easy for these eight, but we've got ten spaces to fill:

What are two more actor articles that people would be searching for, which are substantive, and/or which are very popular?


....I don't know if we should put Rose Leslie or not. People will be looking for her but her character just died. But there's also Liam Cunningham, Carice van Houten, Isaac Hempstead-Wright....oh of course, GWENDOLINE CHRISTIE!

Tell you what, I'll put up Gwen and Rose for now, and we'll eventually remove Rose during the lead-up to Season 5. --The Dragon Demands (talk) 01:25, July 3, 2014 (UTC)

Production menuEdit

I've redesigned the "Production" part of the "Production" menu to be two dropdown lists: one is "Production by department" listing "Deborah Riley- Set designer", "Michele Clapton - Costume designer", etc. The other is "Production topics": things like "Production timeline", "Title sequence", "Game of Thrones (TV series)", and "Differences Between books and TV series".--The Dragon Demands (talk) 21:03, July 5, 2014 (UTC)

Characters on Main Page Edit

I think it's time to change the character images on the main page. For starters Tywin, Joffrey and the Hound are dead or presumed dead in the Hound's case, and Roose isn't played by one of the starring cast. Also I think the images themselves could do with updating. Brienne's in particular looks quite bad. I'm not good with images so I'm more asking for help on this one. Possible new order could be...

Bran, Arya, Sansa, Jon, Samwell,
Cersei, Jaime, Tyrion, Bronn, Margaery,
Stannis, Melisandre, Davos, Petyr, Varys,
Dany, Jorah, Brienne, Ramsay, Reek.

What do you guys think? Rachel P 03:16, July 19, 2014 (UTC)

I wrote about that at length a bit further up this page, but thanks for being on top of this.

Basically, we're still in "post Season 4 mode" but not yet "pre Season 5 mode". As soon as the first teaser trailer for Season 5 comes out, we start redesigning for Season 5 (Some point in late January at the latest).

MANY people are still catching up on Season 4, through Netflix, HBO Go, etc.

Most of the 20 characters in the front page box are "locks" that we wouldn't remove (the core Starks and the core Lannisters).

By a process of elimination, my general idea for how we'd eventually change it when gearing up for Season 5 is:

  • Swap out Joffrey for Tommen.
  • Swap out Tywin for Myrcella.
  • Swap out the Hound for Yara Greyjoy.

We've got 4 main Starks on the first row (including Jon Snow; Robb is dead and Rickon is off-screen), plus Samwell Tarly (he's a POV narrator at this point, and stuff like him escaping Craster's Keep with Gilly is "told" entirely from his perspective even within the TV series).

We have to keep the three core Lannisters: Cersei, Jaime, Tyrion. We're eventually going to swap out Tywin for Myrcella (advanced reports say they've going to invent new scenes for Myrcella, which plausibly happened "off screen" in the books -- which is great, she's one of my favorite characters), plus Tommen replacing Joffrey because he's king now (he doesn't do that much due to being so young, but the plots at court center around him).

So the first half of the boxes are fairly obvious. The second half gets more tricky:

At the very least, we need Daenerys, Stannis, and Margaery, given that they are "faction leaders" (Targaryen, Baratheon of Dragonstone, and...Margaery is more the "face" of Tyrell political intrigue in the show than Loras or Mace ever were, while I don't know if Olenna will reappear...if we have only one Tyrell slot I'd use Margaery over Olenna, whether to have Olenna replace one of the others is a separate issue...)

Yara Greyjoy will replace the Hound because he's presumed dead, and because after the ironborn were shoved completely to the side in Season 4, I can only hope that they will follow the ironborn-heavy subplots of Book 4 which happen after Tywin dies (well, unless we count the Moat Cailin stuff; but as a "political viewpoint", Season 2 showed us Balon and Yara planning....now there's been no Balon and Yara is in only 3 minutes of screentime). Littlefinger remains the "faction leader" of the Vale I guess and by the books should have more to do next season, he's a major player. I'm...not sure, if Varys will be in Season 5 that much so that's up in the air (after he flees King's Landing he isn't "on the page" in the book, then later they give an infodump retroactively explaining what he was doing in that time (similar to how Stannis would be "off screen" for chapters at a time in book 2, but the TV series decided to just show what he did chronologically). If Varys isn't in the first two episodes of Season 5 we might want to swap it out for Olenna Tyrell...but what if she doesn't reappear in Season 5 either? (And of course, if Dianna Rigg wins an Emmy Award next month, all previous arguments fall by the wayside and we put her on the front page!)

The final line of the character boxes is the most random. As I said Yara will get the Hound's spot, and Brienne of Tarth needs her spot. This leaves the "Bolton" perspective of Roose, Ramsay, and Reek. Theon/Reek is a "Viewpoint" character so I think he should be in there. Ramsay is one of the major villains.

Fundamentally, though, I didn't put together the character boxes according to arbitrary TV definitions of "main cast member" or "credited as a guest actor". This is based on the book/story mythos, how relatively important they are (technically Bronn appears more than Catelyn, but he isn't as important within the overall plot; Tywin doesn't relatively have that much screentime in Season 1, but he's very important). Roose is one of the main villains in the story (he's ruling the North now for the Lannisters and personally killed Robb Stark). He didn't appear that much in Season 4 but his presence was large (everything Ramsay is doing is to impress him) and going by the books, now that he's back in the North he'll have even more to do in Season 5 (securing Bolton rule over the other beaten Northern houses).

....wait let's see now...

You're suggesting we include Bronn, Melisandre, Davos, and Jorah.

....well my argument for that is that they're basically "access points". The infoboxes are how people who don't know how to navigate a wiki access different sub-plots. Why have a box for Rickon in Season 2, when Bran is always with him? Etc. The problem is that Bronn isn't very independent of Tyrion in the TV series/books, and Davos and Melisandre are also pretty much always with Stannis. There's just too much overlap. Similarly, all of Jorah's scenes involve Daenerys.

...but then we've got the whole "musical chairs" effect: the design you suggested leaves out Tommen...and he's kind of more important than Bronn, what with being the king on the Iron Throne. Choosing between the two I'd put Tommen over Bronn. The Hound was such a major character in Season 4 that I don't think we should replace him with Melisandre (particularly because the Hound won't be appearing after this, so let him have his time in the limelight).

Brienne's image is indeed bad, it's just what I had available at the time. Yes it needs updating. It would drastically be sped up if anyone loads a properly cropped and sized Brienne image (though then we have to choose a nice angle of her, that's always subjective...).

Oh crud this went on really long. At any rate the major points are:

1 - So many people are still catching up on Season 4 that I am consciously putting off a redesign until we gear up for Season 5, around Christmas/January. The Hound may be dead "now", but taking "Season 4" as a whole unit, he's present throughout it. People looking for information about the Hound after they just watched an episode he's in would need him on the front page.

2 - Due to a process of elimination, I already figured out that the best choices would be to replace Joffrey with Tommen, Tywin with Myrcella, and the Hound with Yara Greyjoy. If Varys isn't in Sesaon 5 that much we'd swap him out for someone else.

3 - The bad quality of the Brienne image has indeed been gnawing at me, if you post up variant cropped Brienne images we can pick a better one.

--The Dragon Demands (talk) 03:53, July 19, 2014 (UT

Makes sense if we look at it from a point of view of faction leaders instead of main cast. I hadn't thought of that to be honest with Roose being the only non main cast up there, though if we throw in Tommen, Myrcella and Yara in that'll be less obvious. So I'm okay with it not being just main cast as long as it's not just one guy who doesn't fit. I still disagree about Roose though. The Bolton storyline is much smaller than say Dany's in the show and yet she is only represented by herself and they have Roose, Ramsay and Reek (the 3 Rs). Jorah is also a viewpoint character like Reek and any of his new stuff will not be in Dany's presence so I think he's a much better fit. As for faction leaders he is more a subordinate than say Mance who is one of the many Kings. Also there are more than one new characters coming (though exactly who survives the cut is yet to be seen) who would easily be better as representative to story lines than him. I won't name any for spoiler reasons but I think you can guess who I mean.

As for your idea of holding off a while before going to season 5 mode I can accept this. I would suggest however that the Tommen/Joffrey swap is far back enough in the season to happen now. I mean you had Joffrey's face up much higher on the page and larger when he died the moment it happened so it's hardly worth keeping that a secret anymore. Giving Tywin and the Hound some more time in the limelight now is perfectly understandable as it's still fresh for people.

Also yes I understand the issue with not knowing how much we'll see Varys or Olenna (and whether or not she recieves the Emmy she deserves). Personally I expect to see more Varys than Olenna in the show, even though this is opposite to the books, but who knows at this stage.

And sorry like I said. I'm bad with images so I really won't be much actual help here. Rachel P 12:48, July 19, 2014 (UTC)

I have a selection of already made portal pictures that I have made, you can use them for the main page if you want? http://gyazo.com/79d0a088b1d9ce8fd63429d3b19b35cb That is just an example of the ones that I have, there are more for the rest of the main characters but I couldn't fit them all into the screenshot. If you're interested just let me know who you want pictures for. :) CoyoteDork (talk) 17:24, July 19, 2014 (UTC)

Also if you choose to use some characters that actors aren't billed as starring, I also have some photos for a few more, such as - http://gyazo.com/6ccae2c7b7cecb3208f857936f9e8c38 Again if you're interested in using these, just let me know who you want the photos for. And if there's someone I don't have a picture for at the moment, I would be more than happy to make one. :) CoyoteDork (talk) 17:28, July 19, 2014 (UTC)

So what do you thinnk? CoyoteDork (talk) 14:07, July 25, 2014 (UTC)

I prefer some of these to the current images (assuming the red/green borders can be removed) though personally think images from the latest season would be best to keep it feeling up to date. The template is protected from non-admin edits though so its really up to The Dragon Demands. I'm just throwing in ideas. Thanks for the suggestion. Rachel P 04:18, July 28, 2014 (UTC)

Let me stress this again: there can only be about 25 character images on the front page portal because that's as many as will fit. If we made ones for all cast members billed as "starring" they wouldn't fit.

Second, crediting as "starring" is absolutely meaningless in a book adaptation. Shae was billed as starring in Season 4 for pay reasons, but in terms of overall impact on the storyline, Roose Bolton is a far more important character. We shouldn't blindly fit it into a TV-first mentality; we know how important Roose is, and even within the TV show ignoring the books he's more important.

Third...this is confusing: http://gyazo.com/6ccae2c7b7cecb3208f857936f9e8c38 Why bother to make character portal images for...Irri, Ros, or Maester Luwin, at this point?

There are only 25 slots, more would be far too large, we're discussing priorities among these slots.

As I have explained, going by the major families, few of these slots seem particularly up for grabs.

The current plan is:

  • Swap out Joffrey for Tommen.
  • Swap out Tywin for Myrcella.
  • Swap out the Hound for Yara Greyjoy.

Varys is also sort of "on the fence" at this point. I dread if they don't use Yara prominently next season (going by the books they should, she's a major character in book 4).

The next most prominent ones we might want to swap in are Olenna Tyrell or....I'm toying with the idea of making a group-shot image linking to "Sand Snakes", given that they seem to be prominent next season.

And I'd bump out Varys for Olenna automatically if Diana Rigg wins an Emmy in a few weeks :)

....you're right, enough time has passed that I'm going to swap out Joffrey for Tommen immediately.

(I'm worried I sound like I'm shouting, I'm not)

Well what we're discussing now is "who should the 25 front page characters be" - I hope everyone is sympathetic that this is a huge cast of characters.

A second, separate question is "should we add more than 25 to the front page, or would this make the front page look far too complicated?" (if we didn't, there can't be any more vertical columns because five across is as many as will fit; we might be able to add one, possibly two more lines....but I'm very hesitant because it might make it difficult to read...--The Dragon Demands (talk) 01:57, August 9, 2014 (UTC)

I don't think we should add more rows, but if we did, these are at the top of the list in terms of who we might want on the front page:

(First, we've got Tommen replacing Joffrey, Myrcella replacing Tywin, and Yara Greyjoy replacing the Hound)

...hmmm...

If Varys doesn't appear prominently in Season 5, we might replace him with a combined "Sand Snakes" icon. I don't know if we also need a Doran Martell one or if we'll do what we did with Oberyn and just make him the featured article.

Davos and Melisandre are good, but plausibly they can be redundant with Stannis.

I don't know how much Bronn will appear in Season 5. He has one really important point he takes part in but otherwise is "off screen" for much of the next book (i.e. I see him as dominating one full episode)...oh crap but there are rumors that he's going to become Jaime's new aide-de-camp in the TV version.

In the grand scheme of things, Missandei and Grey Worm aren't too important, Ser Barristan somewhat moreso, but all three are redundant with Daenerys, just as Davos is redundant with Stannis. We might want to put Missandei up there just so we get some representating for a black woman of color in what is otherwise mostly white men. I don't know.

Pycelle is nice but unlike Littlefinger or Varys he isn't his own "faction"; he's part of Team Lannister.

Loras gets more to do in the books at this point, just as Yara Greyjoy does....

Edmure and Brynden if they reappear Kevan and Lancel if they reappear

The five characters who rank behind the proposed 25 (if they die, etc.) would be....

  • Olenna Tyrell (for now, but we'd remove her if she is confirmed to not return in Season 5 at all)
  • "Sand Snakes" - that way we can refer to many characters with one slot.
  • Doran Martell (or Oberyn if we do this before we get a set photo of Doran in costume)
  • Loras Tyrell
  • Bronn

If we added yet another row, for thirty-five characters....

  • Davos
  • Melisandre
  • Missandei
  • Grey Worm
  • Ser Barristan

...though we might replace one of these with Brynden or Edmure, or perhaps replace two with Brynden AND Edmure.

(if Varys doesn't reappear in early Season 5 we'll replace him with Kevan Lannister...if, dear god, Kevan returns in Season 5 because he becomes more prominent after his older brother Tywin dies in the books).

But at the moment I am against adding more rows, I think it would be "unwieldy" to have a character table that large.--The Dragon Demands (talk) 02:16, August 9, 2014 (UTC)

Tommen but not Melisandre or Davos?--Gonzalo84 (talk) 05:54, August 9, 2014 (UTC)

Well Tommen is the "King on the Iron Throne" at the moment.--The Dragon Demands (talk) 16:03, August 9, 2014 (UTC)

I was agreeing more with CoyoteDork's choice of images rather than choice of characters. I never said anything about extra rows and agree we don't need any more. Also yes, I agree Tommen deserves a spot if we are using the faction leaders criteria as the current king on the throne . I do still feel however that under that rationale that Mance is a much better fit than Roose. The wildlings/freefolk are not represented at all otherwise and he is one of the kings, whereas the argument you've for Davos etc being redundant with other characters definitely applies to Roose/Ramsay (more so than Davos or Melisandre in my opinion) and while he may represent one part of the Lannister forces, Mance represents an entire society/army. Also personally I think that Doran as opposed to Myrcella and possibly the sand snakes works better as a representative of both the ongoing story and a faction leader. I don't care as much about about that one as I do about swapping Roose for Mance though.Rachel P 04:50, August 11, 2014 (UTC)

Top Navigation BarEdit

The Top Navigation Bar works like this:

There are three levels: Level 1, Level 2, and Level 3. It is impossible to make a fourth sub-level.

Level 1 things at the moment on here are "On the Wiki", "Episodes", "Characters", "Production", and "Community". Of these, we have absolutely no control over what's in "On the Wiki" - it doesn't show up in the editor (which only Admins can access) and it's controlled by Wikia. Which isn't necessarily helpful because we might want to combine some other stuff into it.

Level 2 things are what shows up when you hover your mouse icon over it. So for the Level 1 "Episodes", the Level 2 menu items are "Season 1", "Season 2", etc.

Level 3 is a drop-down menu based on things in Level 2. So you hover over "Season 1", and it shows a sub-list. The Level 2 header can be a link itself, though, so if you have the "Season 2" dropdown bar open, it's limited to ten episode slots, but you can click on the word "Season 2" to get to the Season 2 article.

We have control over at most 4 Level one menu items; each Level 2 menu can physically hold no more than 7 items -- nothing to do with word length. It's limited to 7. Then, every Level 3 dropdown menu can have no more than 10 items in it. Thus we can at most put as many as 4x7=28, 28x10 = 280 items into the Top Navigation Bar.

The Admin-level Top Navigation Bar editors also doesn't have a History tab, so you can't really see past versions to re-use an older format, but the overall page is short enough that this usually isn't a problem.

So what we've got now are "Episodes", "Characters", "Production", and "Community".

Not much is going to change with "Episodes", it's one of the major Access Points that casual readers use. So it's listed by Season. I'm going to take the "Overview" menu out though - we've got a lot of seasons, and "Overview" is a list of "Season 1", "Season 2", etc....which is redundant with how the "Season 2" dropdown menu is itself a link to Season 2.

In its place I want to put a link to the "Histories and Lore" animated featurettes, to make them more visible (MANY people who just casually watch the show don't know about those).

That would give us 5 seasons plus Histories and Lore to make six items. When we reach Season 7 (if not Season 8...) that means we won't have room for "Histories and Lore" (and if we really have Season 8, we simply won't have room for every season). So when we reach that point, we'll leave a dropdown menu for the more recent seasons like "Season 7", "Season 6", etc...but we might have to combine "Seasons 1-3" into a single dropbar, consisting of just "Season 1", "Season 2", and "Season 3", and users will then go back to those episodes from the episode listings on each of those (the actual link would hopefully go straight to the episode list section of the "Season 1" page.

But that's a long way off, and we'd postpone it as much as possible. Not an issue in Season 5 or Season 6.

And we'd of course need to make more combinations if we ever get a prequel project or something, Dunk & Egg, Dance of the Dragons, etc.

Characters is also probably a good setup. A lot of casual readers search by characters.

Limited to only 7 Level 2 headers, I went with Stark, Lannister, Baratheon, Tyrell, Greyjoy, Martell, and Targaryen.

Each "character group" I put there isn't strictly everyone under that family name, but "family and allies" - there aren't enough Tullys to justify using up one of the 7 Level 2 headers, so "Randyll Tarly" would go under Tyrell, "Grey Worm" under Targaryen, Areo Hotah under "Martell", etc.

The other factor is that we're limited to only 7 Level 2 headers, and only up to 10 Level 3 items in the drop-down menus. So I combined the Tullys into the Starks, as part of the "extended Stark family" but also Stark allies, so that's why Brynden and Edmure Tully are under the Stark menu.

Some of these turned out fairly well: "Stark" is Eddard and Catelyn, Eddard's 6 children to make 8, then Brynden and Edmure round it out to 10. Lannister is Tywin and his three children (4), then Jaime and Cersei's three children (7), plus Kevan and Lancel (9). It's good that Lancel will be appearing against in Season 5.

One snag is that allegiI wasn't really sure what to put as the tenth and last Lannister item...so I just put Ser Pounce. People like Ser Pounce. I couldn't put one of Lancel's brothers because if I put Martyn, why not Willem? And even then they're dead at this point. As for major bannermen, they didn't really set up anyone other than the Cleganes and they're both either dead or not recurring prominently.

...I didn't put Bronn in because his "allegiance" at this point is kind of dubious. He was working for Tyrion but he's not anymore, and in the books at least, he stops "working" for the Lannisters as a whole at that point - he married into House Stokeworth. Then again, given that reports say Season 5 will have Bronn continuing to work "with" Jaime on an embassy trip to Sunspear, might it make sense to include Bronn in the list?

"Baratheon" includes the three Baratheon brothers (Robert, Stannis, Renly), plus Stannis's wife and daughter (5), plus Robert's bastard son Gendry (6 - he's the only prominent and recurring bastard in the TV series version). Round that out with Melisandre, Davos, and Salladhor (Team Stannis), and Brienne of Tarth (Team Renly...I'd have put her with the Starks/Tullys if we had more room...though as a Stormlander, she sort of fits under Baratheon, and she was part of Renly's Kingsguard). So there's nothing to change there.

The Martell and Targaryen ones also turned out pretty well, a full list of ten, without omitting anyone too big. Martell is siblings Doran, Elia, Oberyn, then "Sand Snakes" as well as the three prominent Sand Snakes (7), Ellaria and Trystane (9), then Areo Hotah to make 10 (prominent servant/team member, prominent character, book POV character).

In the event that they later cast Arianne Martell, we'll either take "Sand Snakes" out, or take out "Elia Martell" because she died before the series started (though she is a central influence on the actions of the surviving Martells). Not sure. And if we get both Arianne and Quentyn we might have to take out the three individual Sand Snake articles but leave in the main "Sand Snake" page. I'm not sure. But we'll decide that when they cast Arianne...and that's a problem we want to have! I doubt Quentyn will appear in the TV version though.

Targaryen is also fairly clear: Daenerys and Viserys, plus Rhaegar and their father the Mad King (4), plus Maester Aemon (5). Then Daenerys's major allies, including Missandei, Grey Worm, Barristan Selmy, Jorah Mormont, and Khal Drogo.

...anyone think we should remove Khal Drogo eventually? This listing works through Season 4, but if Hizdahr or other supporters in Slaver's Bay become more prominent, then what? It doesn't have room for Daario Naharis. By Season 5, should we swap out Jorah Mormont, and replace him with Daario? Because Jorah isn't actually "serving" her at the moment.

The two that gave me trouble were the Tyrells and Greyjoys. Instead of fitting everyone in, the problem with the other lists...this was too few, relative to using up one out of seven Level 2 headers.

They've only introduced four Tyrells in the TV series: Loras, Margaery, Olenna, Mace. With six more spots to fill, I rounded it out with Randyll Tarly and Samwell Tarly, on the logic that Randyll is a "Tyrell bannerman". Yes, Samwell is now a member of the Night's Watch, but then again, so was Jon Snow, but he's still listed under "Stark" for convenience.

The Greyjoys have only appeared in two out of the past twenty episodes! For a grand total of five minutes! (Not including Theon's torture scenes, which aren't really showing "The Greyjoys" as a faction).

So far we've only got Balon, Yara, and Theon/Reek. I tried to round this out with adding the three uncles who haven't appeared yet but who become major characters in book 4...and thus logically, SHOULD become major characters by Season 5. But both Tyrell and Greyjoy only use 6 spots each, leaving a total of 8 spots that we could fill but cannot.

Open sorting questions are:

1 - So far I've been listing "Ser Pounce" as the tenth Lannister link. Going by the books, Bronn isn't really serving the Lannisters anymore...but we know he's going to be tagging along with Jaime in Season 5. Might that justify including him?

2 - Should the Targaryen list remove Jorah Mormont and replace it with Daario Naharis?

3 - Should we eventually remove Khal Drogo from the Targaryen list, and put in a more important Season 5 character, such as Hizdahr zo Loraq? (Probably going to hold off on that until Season 5 actually airs).

4 - In the event that they ever cast Arianne Martell, we may need to reshuffle the Martell list in such a way that it removes either "Elia" or "Sand Snakes". But that's a problem we want to have.

5 - The Small Council characters didn't fit in anywhere: Varys, Littlefinger, Pycelle. Neither did Lysa, who was important in Season 4 but who's dead now. Littlefinger is even a faction unto himself. Granted, a lot of these are on the front page character boxes anyway.

6 - The Boltons and Freys didn't fit in anywhere.

So I might toy around with combining those two Tyrell and Greyjoy categories to make use of the 8 slots we're otherwise miss.--The Dragon Demands (talk) 02:01, October 18, 2014 (UTC)

Screw it, I'm adding Bronn in Ser Pounce's place on the Lannister tab. He was in Season 4, and we've seen that he'll be helping Jaime in Season 5.--The Dragon Demands (talk) 02:02, October 18, 2014 (UTC)

I have decided to remove the Greyjoys, and redivide the other characters.

I didn't want it to come to this, but fundamentally, unless they get around to casting Balon's three brothers, we have ONLY three major ironborn characters: Balon, Yara, and Theon....and even the HBO Viewer's Guide gets away with listing him as "Reek" under their House Bolton section.

So faced with the other pressures of getting "royal court" members, Boltons and Freys in there somehow....people who know who Yara Greyjoy is can find her well enough, or use the front page navigation. The VERY casual readers who have trouble finding their way around? They're more dependent on looking for articles about characters who appear more frequently.

So I removed the Greyjoy list, and the Tyrell list.

The two lists I replaced them with are "At court" and "Boltons/Freys" (which I feel are a conceptual unit; the betrayers who switched to the Lannister side at the Red Wedding).

So the new lists look like this:

  • Royal court
  • House Baratheon of King's Landing
  • Small Council
  • Pycelle
  • Littlefinger
  • Varys
  • House Tyrell
  • Margaery
  • Loras
  • Olenna
  • Mace
  • Boltons & Freys
    • House Bolton
    • Roose
    • Ramsay
    • Reek
    • Fat Walda
    • House Frey
    • Walder Frey
    • Black Walder Rivers
    • Lame Lothar Frey
    • Roslin Frey

The Bolton/Frey list is fairly straightforward, it includes Reek, the more prominent Freys, and I rounded it out by simply putting "House Bolton" and "House Frey" in it as list items, to navigate to. The Level 2 header needs to link to something, though (it automatically links to "Boltons & Freys" if you leave it blank)...so, I linked that to "Red Wedding" - popular, long page fairly-well developed, and it's the event where both the Boltons and Freys came to power.

The "Royal Court" one was a bit more tricky. Oh, I had to retitle it as "At Court" - please don't change this - because even besides the limit of seven Level 2 headers...the names in the Level 2 bar were getting so long that the ones at the end, the Targaryens, were getting cut off at the edge. I can read the Targaryen entries now in MY browser, but do they display well for everyone else using other screen sizes or browsers? Anyway, that's why I had to truncate it from "Royal Court" to "At Court".

...okay, another quick fix is that I switched "Martell" and "Targaryen" so now Martell is the right-most. Martell names tend to be slightly shorter than Targaryen names, I hope that helps (actually, GRRM intentionally made Targaryen names long and complicated - the Valyrians were the powerful, refined, imperial culture. First Men names are intentionally simple: "Stark", "Jon", etc. Andal names like "Loras Tyrell" are kind of in-between).

"At Court" is actually a list of the Small Council, and House Tyrell. Everyone else already fits under "House Lannister" (the two are kind of synonymous at the moment). The only exception is that the very first one listed is "House Baratheon of King's Landing"...and I have the title itself link to "Red Keep".

So again, like Boltons and Freys, I rounded out the list by making what would be the header on the shorter lists just the top entry: "Small Council" followed by Pycelle, Littlefinger, and Varys, then "House Tyrell", followed by the four main Tyrell characters. Yeah, I know that Littlefinger and Varys aren't really at court anymore, but they're major characters, and it's sort of the best place that fit. They are "of" the royal court, they were there fore many years, etc. Also considering the wiki as a whole, going through past seasons. Generally I think that works.

...Maybe instead of linking to "Red Keep" it can link to "House Baratheon of King's Landing", freeing up another slot. But who else is there? Qyburn? Okay, unless there are objections, I'll make "At Court" link to House Baratheon of King's Landing, and put "Qyburn" in that slot.

Otherwise we lost a link to "House Greyjoy", "Balon Greyjoy", and "Yara Greyjoy" but...the really casual readers who rely only on the Top Bar really wouldn't be looking for them. The Top Bar is for browsing-navigation, not people who know what they're looking for. And they sadly haven't used the Greyjoys enough. We can update this in Season 5 if things change.

So, thoughts on this? Suggestions?--The Dragon Demands (talk) 03:25, October 18, 2014 (UTC)

Top Navigation Bar - ProductionEdit

So of the four Level 1 Top Bar items we have control over, "Episodes" and "Characters" are pretty much in place. The next one I set up is "Production".

It currently only has six Level 2 sub-menus, when it can sustain up to seven, but I'm not sure what else to add.

The Level 2 menus I put in are Writers, Directors, Crew by Department, Actors, and "Production topics". The sixth one I added in was "Merchandise" -- not exactly a "Production" topic, but it is also "out of universe"..."Merchandise" doesn't really fit in "Episodes" or "Characters",

"Writers" was pretty easy, there have only been seven writers on the show: Martin, Benioff, Weiss, Espenson (Season 1), Taylor (Season 2-3), Cogman, and Hill (starting in Season 5, but an assistant before that and writer of "Histories and Lore").

"Directors" was a bit more difficult because there have been more than 10 directors. So I put in a mix of A - Directors who will be in Season 5, B - prominent past directors (i.e. Michelle MacLaren)....hmmm...maybe I can use the extra seventh slot to just divide "Directors" into two big sections.

"Actors" was a bit hard but I picked the ones I figure people are most likely to search for, overlapping with those we have developed the most. So it's: Dinklage, Harington, Clarke, Williams, Turner, Headey, Coster-Waldau, Dormer, Christie, and Leslie. Didn't have enough space for Kristian Nairn, but he's not even going to be back next season.

The next one is "Crew by Department", which is all of the other major production team members besides writers and directors: stuff like Michele Clapton (Costume designers), Gemma Jackson and Deborah Riley (Set Design), David Peterson (Languages), etc. etc. Pretty much managed to fit all of the major ones onto one list.

After that I put "Production Topics" - other behind-the-scenes production-related articles that didn't fit elsewhere: Game of Thrones (TV series), Dunk & Egg prequel, Production Timeline, Title sequence, Difference between books and TV series (which is itself a menu page directing to the series of "Differences" pages), Pronunciation guide, Sexposition. Then "Soundtracks" and "Video effects production companies", which actually link to the category pages for those.

Currently there are only nine things in "Production Topics" though, not sure what could be put as a tenth thing.

And then as I said I put a Level 2 link to "Merchandise" just because there was space, Production is also "out of universe", and because Merchandise certainly didn't fit elsewhere.

...hmm...maybe I should make two Level 2 Director menus and just split them in half...--The Dragon Demands (talk) 18:51, October 18, 2014 (UTC)

Alright, done. Had to cut the names down to "Crew" and "Production" (for "Production topics") to get them all to fit on the screen (you're limited to seven Level 2 subheaders, but if they're all really longs names it can't display).--The Dragon Demands (talk) 23:55, October 18, 2014 (UTC)

Top Navigation Bar - CommunityEdit

...does anyone use this thing? It's the only other Level 1 Nav Bar item we're allowed to have...and it's kind of going to waste.

Level 2 headers include: Basic Information, Community Forum, Policies - Parent Page, the drop-down menu for "Help Pages", and Affiliates.

The only Level 3 dropdown menu is the "Help Pages" list, which is actually just auto-generated from linking to the "Help" category: "Index", "Help Desk", "Overview Categories", "Instruction: Images", and the "Welcome" template. The Forum actually has two subdivisions: "Watercooler" is what we think of as "The Forum" -- we use it infrequently enough that we didn't really need another sub-forum. The other Forum subdivision is actually "Help Desk" but...it's only had four threads in the past two years. It's redundant, anyone looking for help usually just posts to the Forum anyway (or Admin talk page). "Index" is also just the "Forum index", showing "Watercooler" and "Help Desk".

So what's left on Level 3? "Overview Categories", "Instruction-Images", and the "Welcome" template.

...No one really uses these for Navigation (at least I think they don't), and these last three we could just put into the automated Welcome message (new accounts will see "This is how images work", the categories, etc. etc.)

....and the same could be said for "Policies" as well as "Basic information". All of this could be in the Welcome message, or, quickly listed in the Community messages displayed on the "Recent changes" page.

...the only thing in the entire Level one "Community" Navigation tab that we actually use is "Community Forum" (which links to the "Watercooler" subforum...which is really the only subforum). That an "Affiliates" -- I'm not sure where else to put that.

So the only two things we have a great need to salvage as menu items are a Forum link and Affiliates. Well...we could also put those in the "Community messages" on the "Recent changes" page.

...a Level 1 menu tab can have 7 Level 2 tabs, each with a dropdown menu containing 10 items each....that's potentially *70 menu links* which are sort of going to waste, for only 2 we would really use now (plus "Help" stuff which sort of fits in a Welcome message anyway).

So as an experiment, I'm going to try replacing the "Community" tab with a "Culture & Society" tab...which is basically the specific pages which weren't "Episodes" or "Characters" -- thematic stuff.

We usually notice new Forum posts in "recent changes" anyway. We could ask the Wikia Staffers to play around with the CSS code eventually to add a "Forum" ink in the open slot under "On the Wiki". Not sure how Affiliates works.

But again...basically weighing maybe 2 links we actually use with potentially Seventy.--The Dragon Demands (talk) 02:12, October 19, 2014 (UTC)


Top Navigation Bar - Culture & SocietyEdit

Okay, I've removed the old "Community" tab which we weren't really using, and transferred the two or three links of note into the "Community Messages" page which shows up in "Recent changes".

In its place, I have constructed a new "Culture & Society" Level 1 menu tab.

The seven Level 2 menus it contains are: Timeline, Organizations, Religions, Social groups, Laws & Customs, Peoples in Westeros, and Peoples in Essos.

...now to make it all fit on-screen, I had to shorten the names to "Groups", "Customs", "Westeros", and "Essos", but I think the meanings are still fairly obvious.

"Customs" (Laws & Customs) is basically thematic stuff that didn't fit in the other categories: Currency, Food & Drink, Languages, etc.

I also moved "Production" to the right-most end, because it's "out of universe" while "Culture & Society" has more to do with the two other "In-universe" things, Episodes and Characters.

Does everyone think this setup is good?

Is it displaying well on other people's web browsers, without getting cut off?

Also, were there any typos I made which make the links not work? (I had to fix "Guest Right" to "Guest right" lowercase, the title is case-sensitive).--The Dragon Demands (talk) 20:49, October 19, 2014 (UTC)

Around Wikia's network

Random Wiki